Prepare to be fooled by Pirates
On April Fool's Day weekend, one question must be posed.
Are the Pittsburgh Pirates trying to fool the public?
The Bucs open the 2006 season Monday in Milwaukee, closing the book on an off-season that saw the organization singing the praises of free agent signees Jeromy Burnitz, Joe Randa and Roberto Hernandez and touting the return home of first baseman and Upper St. Clair product Sean Casey.
Reality:Burnitz and Randa are 36, Hernandez is 41 and Casey may not be here come season's end, since he is a free agent at the end of this season.Success on the field begins with starting pitching anyway. The Pirates organization points to its young rotation with a seemingly limitless ceiling of potential.
Reality: Oliver Perez, Zach Duke, Paul Maholm and Ian Snell have all of 39 career major league victories between them — and Perez has 27 of those.The fifth starter will be either Brandon Duckworth, who washed out with the Phillies, or Victor Santos, who washed out with the Brewers.Duckworth is 16-21 with a 5.34 earned run average in his big league career while Santos is 17-33 with a 5.00 ERAin his.Still feeling ducky about this season?Hey, it's OK.Let's be honest. A 14th consecutive losing season is likely. But it won't be like any of the previous 13.That's because of who's waiting behind the curtain.When Randa's time at third base in Pittsburgh ends, Jose Bautista's will begin. Bautista had a tremendous spring, hitting .345 with four homers, and is only going to Class AAAso he can play every day.When Casey's time at first base in Pittsburgh ends, Brad Eldred's will begin. Eldred hit 40 total home runs in Class AA, AAAand the major leagues last year — and he's still learning how to hit.When Burnitz's time at right field in Pittsburgh ends, Nate McLouth's will begin. He is bidding to make the team's 25-man roster now and may force a trade of Burnitz sooner rather than later, especially if Burnitz fails to produce high power numbers early in the season.When Duckworth or Santos time in the rotation in Pittsburgh ends, Sean Burnett's will begin. Burnett won five games as a mid-season call-up in 2004 and still won't turn 24 until Sept. 17.No matter how Duke, Maholm, Perez or Snell fare this season, none will be older than 25 by season's end.To expect those guys to become consistent winners this year is asking a bit much. To expect it to happen down the road isn't such a crazy thought.Years ago, there was another team fighting off a string of losing seasons while waiting for group of young starters to mature. Do the names John Smoltz, Tom Glavine and Steve Avery ring a bell?Maybe the Pirates are trying to fool their fans into believing they'll field a winning team in 2006.Be fooled. No problem. Enjoy this interesting mix of youth and veterans this summer.And look forward to what, at last, is awaiting behind the curtain.John Enrietto is sports editor of the Butler Eagle
