Collectors share common thread
BAKERSTOWN, Allegheny County - Usually noted only in its absence, a button is just a way to fasten one part of a garment to another.
Or not.
To a button collector, the fastener doesn't just represent art. It is art. And it comes with art prices.
"Buttons have been made of every natural material," said Lynda Shay of Slippery Rock. "The most I've paid is $150 times four."
That puts Shay on the frugal side. Other collectors don't seem to mind spending $1,000 or more for one button. Avid button collectors will often travel long distances to visit button shows in search of the one button that's just what they're looking for.
A collector for the past decade, Shay favors buttons that feature birds.
"I'm a bird lover," said Shay, who keeps two caged birds at home. Shay also collects buttons decorated with the likenesses of women. "Some of the loveliest buttons you can ever find are of women's heads."
Bejeweled, commemorative or iconic, buttons can be made of almost any hard material, and a few soft ones that have been hardened to the task.
From knots of silken threads to horn, rock and precious metals, they are cut, cast, shaped, painted, baked and bejeweled before being added to clothing.
With buttons, form follows function up to a point. Then they become art forms in and of themselves.
That's where groups like the National Button Society, Pennsylvania State Button Society and the Keystone Button Club, take up the thread.
The Keystone Button Club recently hosted a Shop, Show and Share Day at Bakerstown United Methodist Church. The event brought collectors and small portions of their button collections together.
Thousands of buttons, loose, affixed to cardboard and mounted in frames as themed displays, were on hand at the show. An array of shoe buttons were paired with buttonhooks in some framed arrangements, while glove buttons and their specialized hook were displayed in another frame. Buttons made from lumps of coal and chunks of tooth were exhibited next to marquetry and scrimshaw ones.
Sets of buttons could be bought at the show, possibly with the unlikely aim of attaching them to garments as functional closures.
"There are people who sew them on clothing," admitted Karen Hill of New Kensington, who prefers to wear her buttons as the components of handmade necklaces and bracelets.
According to button collectors, most buttoning is about collecting one great button and making it into part of a larger whole of similar ones.
Buttons resembling cameos are in abundant supply and run the gamut of materials from mother of pearl to plastic, costing from $1 to hundreds of dollars. There's even a line of cameo-like buttons produced by Wedgwood in its signature blue and white.
Mary Mitchell of Oakmont and Betty Fitch of Penn Hills, both charter members of Keystone Button Club, have been buttoning together since 1963.
Mitchell prefers buttons that tell a story. She has one with Rip Van Winkle portrayed on it and another that represents the story of Poseidon and the dolphin. Victorian black glass buttons from the 1880s are also pleasing to her eye.
Fitch admits, "I like everything" and estimates she owns "at least 10,000 buttons." Her husband collects uniform and military buttons, as well.
Many buttons collected are antiques. Faith Strobel of Cabot owns a set made to commemorate the first expedition to the North Pole, in which her kinsman took part as the adventure's doctor. The collection is not for sale.On the other hand, Mary Day of Butler acquired, for free and by chance, a button scraped out of a drawer bottom of a chest about to be refinished."It was a Civil War button, made in the South. I sold it for $100 at a state convention," she said.For getting to know about buttons, "The Big Book of Buttons," by Elizabeth Hughes, is a button collector's best guide, explained Shay."It's a $100 book, and we all have one," she said.And how many buttons does it take to make a collection? Most framed displays include about 20 buttons centering on a specific idea. But that's only a culmination of a single thought.Hill estimates she has "a million" buttons, and Day started her collection 40 years ago after being willed "a box as big as a casket" filled with buttons.No matter how many buttons one has, sometimes it's the one you started with that pleases you most. Pauline Power of Carnegie has a button,a buffed celluloid, two-piece pansy that was on my cape when I was 5-years-old. It's still my favorite."Buttons don't have to be antiques to be worth collecting. Some button manufacturers produce sets to commemorate a recent event such as the United States Bicentennial or a quadrennial Olympics.The button show in Bakerstown featured a framed collection of recently issued china buttons with Beatrix Potter characters painted on them. Buttons such as those can be purchased off the rack in fabric stores."I go to fabric stores to look for buttons to compete in categories at button shows," said Day.Button clubs pick two categories each to enter into competitions, explained Linda Loar, state membership person for the Pennsylvania State Button Society. A category might be buttons that are all black and white or perhaps buttons made of mother-of-pearl with a metal stencil overlay.The collections are mounted into frames, then judged for first-, second- and third-place wins. Cash prizes are awarded: $3 for first place, $2 for second, and $1 for third."It might cost a couple of hundred dollars to make a winning display," Loar said.Button making doesn't belong only to big manufacturers. Strobel and her sister, Hope Boltz, make "studio" buttons, handmade, very limited production pieces.Strobel either casts her own findings -or buys antique findings. She attaches shanks to the backs and sets them with sparkly stones in the style of the late 1800s. Boltz chooses a brush and paints to create the miniature works of art that she seals under a glass lens.Sheila McKay makes buttons in a toaster oven in her Grove City kitchen. She uses polymer clay to sculpt faces, which she later paints. On display at the Bakerstown show was a set of seven of McKay's buttons - Henry VIII of England surrounded by each of his six wives. Heads only.
