Site last updated: Monday, November 16, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Stealth bill used for lawmaker pay hike

From the beginning, House Bill 1521 was unusual. When introduced on May 3, the bill that became the vehicle for the pay raise (Act 44) had only two sponsors: Rep. Ray Bunt Jr., R-Montgomery, and Rep. Mike Veon, D-Beaver.

How unusual was this?

An inspection of the first 750 bills introduced in the House this year found only six bills with just one or two sponsors. Of those, only three were substantive legislation. The other three were property conveyances.

Both sponsors of H.B. 1521 are leaders in their respective caucuses. Bunt is the Republican Caucus secretary and Veon is the Democratic whip.

Prior to the bill’s introduction, Bunt did not distribute a memo inviting other lawmakers to co-sponsor the bill, even though such memos are routine practice for nearly all substantive legislation.

Neither caucus leader found the legislation worthy of a press release, despite the fact that the bill, in its original form, would have saved tax dollars by limiting executive branch salaries.

Nor did either leader find it worth publicizing when their bill passed the House State Government Committee eight days later, on May 11.

Nor did either leader find it worth publicizing when their bill passed the House, without debate, on June 8. In fact, Veon found it more newsworthy to post on his Web site the compelling story of the House Finance Committee voting to restore the state treasurer to the Tobacco Settlement Investment Board.

House passage of the bill on June 8 also occurred without debate. To some, this would be unusual because so few members (only the sponsors and members of the State Government Committee) knew about it. But by June 8, every representative knew about the bill because it was discussed in “caucus” — the closed-door meetings where Republicans and Democrats separately learn about legislation and learn what their leaders want them to do.

And then there was the unusual behavior on July 6.

When the Senate amended H.B. 1521, the House unanimously “insisted” on its original version of the bill — without debate — even though 40 representatives had voted against the original version less than a month before. When the Senate “insisted” on its version, the two chambers fulfilled the procedural requirements for a conference committee to eviscerate the original bill and substitute the pay raise.

In short, it looks like House Bill 1521 was never anything other than what legislators call a “vehicle” — an innocuous place-holder, whose content and procedure were designed to elude public attention until, with the blessing of state Supreme Court rulings, it could transport some other purpose into law.

It appears to be a classic “bait and switch,” which is exactly what happened, without debate, on July 6-7.

Did Bunt and Veon know, when they introduced H.B. 1521 on May 3, that it was a vehicle for the pay raise? If so, how did they know it? If not, why didn't they object when it was used for that purpose?How often has Bunt been the prime sponsor of legislation without asking for co-sponsors?When and how did Bunt and Veon come to collaborate on H.B. 1521? In the absence of a co-sponsorship memo, how did Veon know to co-sponsor the bill?Since H.B. 1521 originally affected only salaries in the executive branch, were they acting at the request of the Rendell administration? If so, who made the request and when? If not, did Bunt and Veon ever approach the administration to inform them of their legislation? If so, whom did they approach and when?Why shouldn't the public conclude that Bunt and Veon introduced H.B. 1521 as nothing more than a bait-and-switch vehicle for a purpose - the pay raise - that they intended all along to hide from the public?If they intended to enact the original purpose of H.B. 1521, why didn't they insist that its language remain in the final version? Why was none of the original language included in the final version? (Veon was, after all, on the conference committee.)Does Act 44 solve the original "problem" they sought to solve with H.B. 1521? If not, when and how do they intend to introduce new legislation to solve the original problem?

When did they know that H.B. 1521 was going to be the vehicle for the pay raise?When the bill was introduced on May 3 without the opportunity for co-sponsorship?On June 22, when the Supreme Court, in the Act 71 gambling case, told the legislature once again how to enact stealth legislation that could pass court muster?Before the Senate amended it on July 6 with three additional lines that would require House concurrence?Before the House unanimously "insisted" on its own version of the original bill on July 6, again without debate?Before the Senate "insisted" on its own version of the original bill on July 6, again without debate?When the conference committee presented the bill to the members of the House and Senate after midnight on July 7?Who were the 40 representatives who voted against the original bill on June 8? Why, on July 6, did they "insist" on keeping the version that they had voted against less than a month before?What misgivings, if any, did they have on July 6 about voting on a bill that was entirely different from the one they had "insisted" upon only hours earlier? Did they insist on their version solely for the purpose of creating the conference committee because they already knew what the conference committee would do?Since all of the original language of H.B. 1521 was removed, how do they propose to solve the problem originally addressed by H.B. 1521 and that they "insisted" be solved in the way they voted on July 6? Do they no longer believe that the original purpose of the bill needs to be addressed?Ironically, as Common Cause has pointed out, H.B. 1521 originally limited the salaries of some executive branch officials rather than increasing salaries across the board.Timothy Potts is a former director of communications for the state House Democratic Caucus. He is a co-founder of Democracy Rising PA.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS