Horse charges refiled
CHICORA — State police have refiled charges against the owner of a northern Butler County campground who is accused of failing to properly care for several horses he owns.
Glen A. Kleinfelter of Washington Township, 57, is again charged with a summary offense of animal cruelty in the nearly year-old case.
The charges were filed Friday at the office of District Judge Lewis Stoughton in Chicora.
Eight days earlier, Stoughton dismissed the same animal cruelty case after the prosecution’s key witness was late for a summary trial.
That witness, Pamela Vivirito, director of Equine Angels horse rescue organization in Jefferson Township, blamed her tardiness on confusion over the date of the trial, which had been rescheduled six times.
Vivirito’s findings during a visit last year to Kleinfelter’s Peaceful Valley Family Campground in Washington Township were instrumental in leading police to file charges.
Based on a complaint by the Butler County Humane Society, she went to the campground on June 2, 2012, and found eight horses “living in unsuitable conditions” and “malnourished,” a police report said. Police charged Kleinfelter on June 11, 2012. The citation issued then is identical to the one refiled Friday.
According to the citation, police allege Kleinfelter “did neglect or deprive the horses of necessary sustenance, drink, shelter or (veterinarian) care ... which has caused their health to deteriorate.”
But Kleinfelter’s attorney, Thomas May, on Monday denied those allegations.
“He did not nor would he ever mistreat his horses,” May said of his client. “He’s 100 percent innocent in this matter.”
Kleinfelter did not return telephone calls Friday and Monday.
When the case was initially filed last June, he denied the charges and defended his care of the animals.
“These are false claims,” Kleinfelter told the Butler Eagle. “My horses are adequately fed and watered and they have adequate shelter.”
However, Vivirito described the animals conditions as deplorable and insisted that the horses appeared underweight.
“Three of the horses, in particular, were in pretty bad shape,” she said Monday. She claimed she could not find any hay, grain or water for the animals, and they had inadequate shelter. Vivirito said Kleinfelter was not there when she made her first visit. The following day, she said, she returned with police.
But by then the three horses that had appeared worse off than the others, were not there, she recounted.
“He had removed them from his property,” she said. “I didn’t know where he took them.”
But Kleinfelter last year argued that his horses were well fed, going through 140 round bales of hay a year.
He said the animals had constant access to water from a stream that flows through the campground and from water-filled tubs.
Additionally, he said a barn was available to sufficiently shelter the horses, and a veterinarian was called when they animals need medical care.
Vivirito said she has not been back to the campground since last June.
That same month, Kleinfelter filed notice with the Butler County Prothonotary’s Office that he intends to sue Vivirito for defamation in the matter.
But that lawsuit has not yet been filed. Mike Gallagher, Kleinfelter’s’ attorney in that matter, was unavailable for comment Monday.
