Bucktail lures are often a good bet in cold water
The term bucktail, particularly at this time of year, most often conjures up images of the trailing appendage of a whitetail buck, perhaps flagging to the sportsman a lost opportunity as the deer bounds away.
But bucktail — that is the hair from a deer's tail — also is a traditional dressing on many fishing lures. In the cold water of late fall and early winter, leadhead jigs employing bucktail are at their best.
With the seemingly endless supply of soft-bodied dressings currently available, it's easy to see why few anglers employ bucktail jigs among their standard offerings.
Go back a couple decades, though, and bucktail jigs, along with marabou (feather) jigs, were commonly used. Bucktails still produce in a variety of cold water fishing situations.
Sid Brown of Greensburg is one skilled angler who knows the productivity of bucktail jigs. Browns and I share the boat many times over the course of the year. It was a few springs ago that he showed me how well bucktail jigs work.
It was an early spring smallmouth bass trip to Lake Erie's Presque Isle Bay. We were using my boat, so Brown had the chance to rig up as we motored to our first spot.
As I attempted to tie on a quarter-ounce plastic tube jig — a productive offering for early season bass in the bay — Brown threw out a white bucktail jig.
On his first cast he announced he had missed a hit. I couldn't help but wonder if in fact he had only ripped a weed, as the spot typically sees weed growth early in the year.
His next cast produced a three-pound smallie. So much for my weed theory.
Throughout that day bucktails outproduced tubes and grubs. On that day my regard for bucktail jigs rose, as well as my confidence in fishing them.
The bucktail jig is the definition of simplicity. A moderate bunch of hair from a deer, typically about three to four inches long, is tied behind the head of a leadhead jig. The thread wrap forms a collar. Natural color is issued, as are various colors created by dying the hair. Materials are available from popular mail order houses if the bounty from your deer hunt was a meager one.
The bucktail jig can be fished in a variety of ways. Basically, the choices can be categorized as either horizontal or vertical presentations.
Horizontal applications include casting the jig and working it back to shore or the boat by way of various retrieves. In vertical fishing the jig is worked underneath the boat similar to a jigging spoon.
Brown said one of the advantages of the bucktail is that it can be fished more aggressively than a jig tipped with livebait. He often will cast the jig up on to a shallow flat and rip the jig back to the boat by snapping the rod tip forward, then reeling up the slack.
He also will use the same action when slowly trolling over a shallow flat. In this case, he casts the jig behind the boat, then simply snaps the jig forward as the boat moves along. Boat movement takes up the slack in this case. A fairly heavy jig of a half ounce or so is used when snapping, particularly when trolling.
To fish a bucktail jig in a vertical manner, you want to position the boat directly over the cover or structure you wish to fish. Lower the jig to the bottom, then crank it up a turn or two on the reel. As you would with a jigging spoon, lift the jigs six inches to a foot by snapping the rod tip upward. Then allow the jig to settle back down on a semi-tight line. Strikes often will occur when the jig is on the fall.
The best places to fish a bucktail vertically often are bends in creek and river channels. Places with stumps of brush are more likely to hold fish than similar places lacking such cover. Fish of many species often concentrate on these bends during the late fall.
Brown often catches smallmouth and largemouth bass, walleye and northern pike from these areas, sometimes from the same particular spot. Other high percentage areas include points that fall off into deep water. Seeing clouds of baitfish on the sonar hanging off of these points increases the likelihood you'll catch game fish jigging a bucktail.
Thanks to its natural, subtle action that mimics a baitfish, bucktail jigs fall into the "your-never-know-what-you'll-catch-on-one" category.
Last fall, my friend Craig Mason of Export caught and released an extremely fat 45-inch muskie on a bucktail jig, a fish that likely pushed the 30-pound mark.
Feel is a big part of the game in bucktail fishing. For that reason Brown uses a no-stretch braided line like Berkley Fireline. He favors high visibility lines in the 8- to 10-pound test range and employs a fluorocarbon leader of a couple of feet on the terminal end. A sensitive spinning rod, one of medium action, is used to fish the jig.
Fish don't hold onto a bucktail as long as they do soft-bodied jigs, so set the hook immediately if you feel you may have a bite. Like fishing legend Al Lindner says, "Hooksets are free."
Like anything in fishing, bucktail jigs are not a magic lure. There are many instances, though, where they are one of the best presentations going.
Jeff Knapp is an outdoors columnist for the Butler Eagle.
