Site last updated: Friday, November 20, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Pitchers' growing pains hurt Pirates

The most loyal of Pittsburgh Pirates fans might be convinced the team is snake-bitten about now.

After all, veteran starting pitcher Kip Wells was lost for half the season because of a blood clot, marquee off-season acquisition Sean Casey broke his back on a seemingly innocent play at first base and actor Michael Keaton publicly blasted the franchise on the day of its home opener for not trying hard enough to win.

All of that happened before the season was two weeks old.

On top of all that, the Pirates lost 12 of their first 17 games and six games during their first 10-game homestand.

But let's be honest. The Pirates are not snake-bitten. They've been bitten by their own starting rotation, a young, inexperienced group of pitchers who have been performing like, well, a young, inexperienced group of pitchers.

Through three starts, Zach Duke is averaging six innings per start. Paul Maholm is averaging 5X\c innings per start while Oliver Perez, Victor Santos and Ian Snell are all averaging five innings per start.

That just won't work in the long run.

Check out the bullpen's numbers. Through 17 games, Salomon Torres has 10 appearances, while Roberto Hernandez, John Grabow and Damaso Marte have eight each.

Project that appearance rate over a full season and Torres would pitch in 100 games, Hernandez, Grabow and Marte nearly 80 each. Again, that won't work.

Overall, the Pirates pitching staff has surrendered 68 walks and 25 home runs.

Duke's earned run average is a semi-respectable 4.50. Based on past performance, there is reason to believe that figure will go down. The ERAs of the other four starters? Try 5.85 for Santos, 6.11 for Maholm, 6.75 for Perez and 9.60 for Snell.

Yes, there is cause for concern here, mainly because the Pirates' options are limited.

Tom Gorzelanny could replace the struggling Snell, as the former has been pitching well at Class AAA Indianapolis. Sean Burnett likely will return to the big club soon and probably will replace Santos when he does.

Even with those moves, Gorzelanny and Burnett are players with no guarantee of immediate success.

The Pirates' fate this season remains in the hands of their starting pitchers. It doesn't matter if Craig Wilson hits 40 home runs, Jason Bay repeats his productivity of last season or Jack Wilson hits .300.

If you can't pitch, you can't win. That statement has been proven time and time again for about 120 years or so.

The Pirates take a 5-12 record into Houston this weekend before they head to St. Louis. Houston plays in a hitters' ballpark and the Cardinals are one of the league's best hitting teams.

It's not too early to consider this a critical road trip. The starting pitchers need to go deeper in games and the bullpen needs to get rest much more frequently.

The only relief pitcher Pirate fans haven't seen much of is Mike Gonzalez.

That's because he only pitches with the lead.

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS