Big things can live in small streams
The axiom "good things come in small
packages" typically isn't associated with muskie habitat. Traditional thinking links big muskies with big water, and it applies most of the time.
Limiting your fishing to that philosophy, however, might mean missing exceptional opportunities for bubba-sized muskies from smaller streams.
A variety of scenarios occur in which muskies can be found in creeks, streams and small rivers, where few, if any, anglers target them. Two of them have the highest potential for larger fish.
Larger rivers that support muskie populations often experience a migration of fish from the main river into smaller tributaries. This is especially common when the water is cold and high.
Movements often begin in the fall, with fish holding in feeder waters until the following spring. How long fish stay in smaller waters is relative to the quality of habitat found in the tributary, water levels, and the available forage found there.
Also, it's common in many reservoirs to have fish escape from the impoundment by way of the discharge. This is particularly prevalent in reservoirs that have fixed-crest spillways, where fish attracted to the current pass over the dam with a relatively low rate of mortality.
The situation is such that on some popular midwestern reservoirs physical barriers have been erected in an effort to keep predators such as muskies (as well as walleyes) in the impoundment. The transplants move downstream until they find suitable habitat, most often in deeper, slow moving pools that feature woody cover. Muskies, including some large ones, show up in unlikely places.
In addition to these two situations, some small rivers and creeks support wild, self-sustaining populations of muskies. This is true in portions of West Virginia, where native fish of the Ohio River strain muskie are found. Other states in the mid-South region feature similar situations.
Add to this smaller rivers with muskie fisheries maintained by stocking activities of the state resource agency. Small river muskie populations fueled by stocking or wild fish tend to be better known, however, and might not offer the trophy potential as the previously described deals.
Howard Wagner, a Western Pennsylvania muskie fishing enthusiast, has been pursuing the them for many years. During the past 20 of them or so, smaller waters have been a focus of his efforts, particularly at this time of year.Of the many muskies he has taken from offbeat waters, four of them have eclipsed the 50-inch range. The heaviest one, a 54½-inch by 28-inch specimen, was caught and released during the late winter and early spring period from a small tributary of the Allegheny River.The released fish, according to popular muskie weight calculation formulas, such as that used by Muskie, Inc., weighed 53.41 pounds. It would have threatened, if not topped, the longstanding Pennsylvania state record of 54.3 pounds set in 1924."When I used to read articles years ago they used to tell you that you've got to have big water to get the bigger muskies," said Wagner. "I've found out that isn't necessarily true. The main thing you need to have, however, is light fishing pressure."Some of the rivers and streams with the highest trophy potential likely have a physical connection with larger waters, situations where the fish can migrate from the larger water up into the smaller one.In the case of escapees from a reservoir, adult fish that have spent much of their lives fattening up on the food found there have bodies not indicative of the more limited forage resources found in their new digs. Also, Wagner has noticed a shift in the type of food fish found in many of the flowing waters he fishes."It seems to me things have changed a lot as far as forage in many streams is concerned," he noted. "Shad and alewife are now in most of the reservoirs in my area. What's happening is almost every stream and small river seems to somewhere have a lake or impoundment in the watershed that feeds into it, one that has a strong forage base."The tributaries of larger rivers that support muskie populations should be one of the first areas to consider for late-fall/winter muskies. These waters are easy to identify on a map. If the main river is dammed up, the elevated pool level of the main river affects the waters that feed it. This means that slack water will extend a fair distance up the feeder water from its merger with the main flow.Depending on the topography of the area, and how far the tributary is located from the dam, the low current area can extend beyond a mile from the creek mouth. Tributaries located closer to the upriver portion of the dam will realize more of a slack water effect.While the creek mouth itself may see fishing pressure, few anglers venture on up the stream, especially if it involves hiking much distance off of a road.These areas, however, often have all the elements needed to hold a muskie. The biggest feature is the reduced current. Add to that plenty of forage. Since the area acts as a transition from the faster water of the free-flowing stream and the main flow of the larger river, typically it piles up with logs and brush washed there during high water events. Deposits from such occurrences also form sand and gravel bars, adding even more to the attraction of the place.The best time to hit the lower end of creeks that feed dammed-up rivers is when the water is high. Beginning in the fall, many muskies may stay in the slow, deep holes. When the water rises, so does the level of current in these "wintering" holes, pushing the fish to areas of reduced current, such as up in the creeks. Years with high water from fall on through spring can provide fishing opportunities the entire time, providing the water doesn't freeze.In addition to the chance to catch muskies during a period when fishing opportunities are limited, the scenario has a certain Indiana Jones appeal to it.No need here for boats loaded to gunnels with equipment and baits. This is a game of a few select lures, a well-chosen rod and reel, minimal terminal tackle, neoprene waders, warm clothes and a high spirit of adventure.Perhaps not a new frontier, but an under-fished one, indeed. Plan to spend time scouting and learning new water because half the fun does lie in getting there.
