Knoch's Carma Forty, right, had nine pins last year as a sophomore. Butler Eagle file photo
Justin Guido/Special to the Eagle
High school girls wrestling is entering just its third season in Pennsylvania, but Butler County has already produced two WPIAL champions — Butler’s Ana Malovich, who is now wrestling at Grand Valley State, won district gold in 2024, and Knoch’s Braylee Ireland won last year.
Ireland is back and hoping for more success as a senior this season, but a number of westlers at Butler, Seneca Valley and Knoch return to the mat after promising efforts a year ago.
The following are nine wrestlers to watch during the 2025-26 season, listed alphabetically:
Carma Forty, jr., 142 pounds, Knoch
She tallied a 14-9 record as a sophomore, including nine pins. She will serve as a team captain.
Butler's Olivia Hageman, top, medaled at the WPIAL girls wrestling tournament last year. Butler Eagle file photo
Olivia Hageman, jr., 235 pounds, Butler
Eighteen of her 21 wins last year were by fall. Earned sixth place in the WPIAL tournament.
Related Article: PA boys basketball: Meet the Top 7 players to watch in Butler County in 2025-26
Seneca Valley's Everly Harrell, right, earned bronze at the WPIAL championship last year. Butler Eagle file photo
Morgan Phillips
Everly Harrell, jr., 106 pounds, Seneca Valley
She placed third in the WPIAL as a sophomore and finished the season with a record of 21-11.
Related Article: Miranda LaJevic’s injury has her helping Knoch wrestling in other ways. It’s just another twist in her back-breaking journey
Seneca Valley's Hannah Hornick, right, won 23 matches last year. Butler Eagle file photo
Morgan Phillips
Hannah Hornick, sr., 170 pounds, Seneca Valley
Her 23 wins last season were third-most among Butler County girls. Qualified for states for the second straight year after placing fourth in the WPIAL and third at regionals.
Knoch's Braylee Ireland, left, took home a sixth-place medal at the PIAA championship last year. Butler Eagle file photo
Morgan Phillips
Braylee Ireland, sr., 124 pounds, Knoch
She will move up a weight class after a banner season at 118 — first place in the WPIAL, first at regionals and sixth in the state.
Related Article: WPIAL girls wrestling: Knoch’s Braylee Ireland ‘feels great’ after winning first district title
Butler's Anastasia Manchester, top, earned pins in all 16 of her wins last year. Butler Eagle file photo
Anastasia Manchester, jr., 136/142 pounds, Butler
Before an injury pulled the plug on her sophomore season, she went 16-7 with all victories coming via pin.
Related Article: Anastasia Manchester, Butler girls wrestling’s dominant middleweight, inspiring younger siblings
Seneca Valley's Adele Shih-Calabro, top, medaled in the district championship last year. Butler Eagle file photo
Morgan Phillips
Adele Shih-Calabro, jr., 112 pounds, Seneca Valley
Entered the postseason unranked at 106 pounds last year, but placed fourth in the WPIAL. Finished with a record of 15-11.
Seneca Valley's Kaeleigh Tuell, left, had an impressive debut season as a freshman, medaling at districts. Butler Eagle file photo
Morgan Phillips
Kaeleigh Tuell, so., 148 pounds, Seneca Valley
She was 21-16 as a freshman and placed fourth in the WPIAL at 155 pounds.
Related Article: PA girls basketball: Meet the Top 8 players to watch in Butler County in 2025-26
Butler's Brin Zehmisch, left, made it to PIAA regionals a year ago. Butler Eagle file photo
Brin Zehmisch, jr., 124 pounds, Butler
She went 21-10 last year and qualified for regionals by placing fourth in the WPIAL.
