Site last updated: Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Katrina turns New Orleans into a ‘Venice from Hell’

What will Hurricane Katrina mean for the United States?

An area the size of Great Britain has just been bombed by Mother Nature. Overnight, New Orleans became “Venice From Hell.” More than a million refugees stream to other cities. Officials warn the Katrina death toll may top 10,000. According to Reuters, economic losses may top $100 billion.

A crisis of this proportion cannot help but reveal who we are.

Few of us will forget the shame of those first dark days: the sight of Americans trapped at the Superdome and the convention center, women and children, old people left with no one to help them, the floating bodies, the collapse of law and order, the revelations of evil among us.

Some people messed up. Some people did worse. Some people grabbed guns and shot at contractors trying desperately to stop the flooding. Some cops in New Orleans heroically struggled to save lives. Some fled. Some did worse. A New Orleans nurse reported on her blog on livejournal.com that the cops stationed at her hospital “went to Dillards and ‘used martial law’ to acquire expensive Polo shirts, jeans, Fendi purses, perfume, candles. . . . Our own cops LOOTED.”

With no al-Qaida to blame, all of us struggle to make sense of the horror, to find a place not only for our displaced neighbors but our displaced sense of security.

As British sociologist Frank Furedi put it on the BBC: “Today, the meaning of a catastrophe, like the one unleashed by Hurricane Katrina, is fiercely contested. There is no one moral story that we are all prepared to accept.” He says that brings a new possibility of double disaster: “One that is about physical destruction and loss of life, and the other which is the legacy of bitterness, confusion and suspicion.”

People react in different ways. Me? At first I found this angry “blame game” splayed across the media just one more horror in a week of horrors. In a natural disaster of this magnitude, people are bound to mess up. Maybe it took 24 hours too long for the feds to respond. Maybe someone should get fired. But for God’s sake, don’t divert people’s attention in the middle of catastrophe to that all-consuming question: Who can we blame?

But maybe I’m wrong. Maybe we should all find it reassuring. Americans expect order, security and abundance. We expect our governments, local, state and federal, to respond to our citizens’ needs, all of them, even those too poor or too stupid to get out of the way of a Category 5 hurricane. We are horrified at failure; success is normal. The infrastructure of three states is wiped out? That’s no excuse for delay.

That’s who we are. The lost life can never be replaced. But because of who we are, I know the other losses will be. I know that this Republican president will pour aid and comfort into the hands of Democratic officials in Louisiana — and every Democratic official hammering Bush’s response to Katrina knows it, too. What a great country to live in.

I know that because of who we are, five years from now, New Orleans and the whole flattened Gulf Coast will be thriving. One hundred billion dollars sucked away by hurricane winds will turn out to be nothing, because America’s wealth — even just our economic wealth — lies in people, not things. If Katrina has revealed evil and incompetence, it will also summon America’s deep human capacity for creativity and community.

Because of who we Americans are, I know that what nature utterly destroyed, we can and will rebuild.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS