Site last updated: Sunday, November 22, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Losing just 1 player can be costly

You would think on a team with 53 players, losing one player would not make that much a difference.

But in the NFL, losing your quarterback can sometimes cost a team its season.

Teams can turn into a shadow of their former selves when the signalcaller is gone.

Sometimes, a player can emerge, like Ben Roethlisberger of the Pittsburgh Steelers last year, subbing for an injured Tommy Maddox.

Even Kurt Warner, taking over for an injured Trent Green back in 1999 for St. Louis, eventually led the team to a pair of Super Bowl games, including a championship title.

But teams with high expectations can see it all fall apart when a quarterback goes down.

Case in point, Roethlisberger.

Without him, the Steelers are 2-2 (Maddox at 0-2, Charlie Batch at 2-0). Unfortunately, Batch was appearing to get comfortable and performing well before he broke his hand late in the first half of the Nov. 13 victory over the Browns.

The Steelers offense went south and looked anemic against Baltimore this past Sunday in a 16-13 overtime loss.

The Steelers will have to hope Roethlisberger can play in the Monday night's game against the undefeated Indianapolis Colts. Another loss will drop Pittsburgh to 7-4 and before a huge AFC North division contest against the co-leader Cincinnati Bengals Dec. 4.

But Pittsburgh is not taking as bad a beating as other teams. Remember Chad Pennington of the New York Jets? He helped the Jets get off to a good start last year, missed a handful of games, then returned to lead the squad to a playoff victory against San Diego before Pittsburgh won in overtime.

This year, Pennington's shoulder troubles emerged early, then he had season-ending surgery. The Jets re-signed 40-year-old Vinny Testeverde and have also used Brooks Bollinger. Where are the championship-caliber Jets today? They're 2-8 and have the second-worst record in the AFC.

What about the Philadelphia Eagles? Four consecutive years they've reached the NFC title game and they advanced to the Super Bowl last year.

But, while star wide receiver Terrell Owens is serving a suspension, quarterback Donovan McNabb has been playing through a sports hernia and the offensive play has deteriorated. People point to the loss of Owens, but a suspect running attack and an injured McNabb has dropped the team to 4-6 and to the bottom of the NFC East.

And don't think any team is safe. Can you imagine if New England's Tom Brady went down? Or the Colts' Peyton Manning.

Brady has led the Patriots to three Super Bowl titles in the past four years. His main backup had been Rohan Davey, but now it's Doug Flutie. It's safe to say that would be a major falloff.

The same with Manning. Jim Sorgi throwing to Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne just doesn't sound the same.

Neither would the results.

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS