Site last updated: Friday, November 20, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Shuffle off to Buffalo for bass

Buffalo, N.Y., is a place that's better known for snow, where East Brady native Jim Kelly played his best football and as the place of origin of some pretty tasty chicken wings.

But it's also the epicenter of outstanding fishing opportunities, highlighted by the smallmouth bass fishing found next to the city in Lake Erie and in Buffalo harbor.

The crown jewel in terms of smallmouth bass fishing is eastern Lake Erie, where the rocky bottom of the lake furnishes ideal habitat for bronzebacks.

Well-traveled angler Mark Davis, the public relations manager for Shakespeare Fishing Tackle, feels the eastern basin of Lake Erie is the top smallmouth destination in the United States.

During an eight-day stint there this spring, Davis reported catching more than 1,000 smallies, a quarter of which he estimated as being greater than four pounds. The top fish were in the seven-pound range.

While the hot springtime fishing has come and gone, Buffalo's summertime smallies are worthy of attention. The action does slow down, however, when the water heats up. Warm water drives the fish to deeper areas. Typically, fishing improves in the fall as the lake cools down.

Rocky bottom habitat is what concentrates Lake Erie smallmouth bass, and this is no different on Buffalo's portion of the lake. Anglers new to the area will find several extensive submerged, rocky humps within a few miles of Buffalo Harbor. The harbor itself, a huge basin encircled by a breakwall, serves as a good backup when the lake is too rough to fish. The rocky corners of the walls are considered the best spots to find bass.

Lake Erie is a border water separating the United States and Canada, so you must be careful not to venture into Canadian waters without being properly licensed. The border is quite close to the eastern end of the harbor, near the Niagara River mouth.

At this time, smallmouths are holding in deeper water. Terry Jones, a seasoned Lake Erie charter captain who specializes in fishing for smallmouth bass, said smallmouths have been taken near humps that rise up out of 40-odd feet of water and top off in the mid-30 foot range. He said shallower humps, ones found in 32 to 34 feet of water and top off in the mid-20 foot range, have also been productive of late. Modern GPS/sonar units, coupled with mapping programs, make finding structures a simple task.

Three main presentations are used for Buffalo-area smallmouth bass:

• Soft plastic tube bodies in a goby pattern are fished with insert-style jigheads. Since the water being fished tends to be deep, it pays to have jigheads in the three-eighths and half-ounce range.

• Drop shot rigging is accomplished by tying a 1 or 1/0 drop shot hook up the line 18 inches to two feet by way of a palomar knot. A drop shot sinker is clipped to the tag end of the line. Heavy sinkers in the half-ounce-and-up range are needed to present a drop shot rig in deeper water.

• While the temperamental smallmouth can often be taken with the soft plastic offering mentioned, there are those days when they want the real thing. Small to medium sized golden shiners, fished on a three-way rig, can turn a slow day into a productive one. Pencil sinkers of at least a half ounce are needed to pull down a livebait three-way rig.

As with any Lake Erie outing, safety is the first consideration. This means an adequate boat equipped with all the safety equipment, as well as a strong dose of common sense.

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS