Other Voices
As a New York Times editor said as his reporter was carted off to prison, you go to court with the case you have, not the case you'd like to have.
Somewhere, Donald Rumsfeld chuckled. So did Franz Kafka. The strange affair of the outed CIA agent and the incarcerated journalist has become that darkly surreal.
No citizen who cares about holding the powerful accountable for their deeds should be laughing, though. Surely no journalist can be happy at how this ambiguous mess has added fuel to the trend of media-bashing.
To sum up, special prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald was called in to investigate whether someone in the Bush administration violated a federal law against revealing the identity of covert CIA operatives.
Times reporter Judith Miller sits in a Virginia jail today because she refuses to name a source to whom she promised anonymity while doing research about the outing of agent Valerie Plame in 2003. Miller, as it happens, never wrote a story.
So, she's in jail for not violating confidentiality concerning an investigation of a violation of confidentiality.
Matthew Cooper, a reporter for Time magazine who did write a short item, was spared from a cell at the 11th hour Wednesday because his source, still unnamed publicly, waived their confidentiality agreement. Even weirder, Fitzgerald is pretty sure he knows who the reporters' sources are.
Meanwhile, Robert Novak, the pundit who started this mess by letting unnamed sources use his column to out Plame, pontificates smugly on, under no threat of compelled testimony or jail, refusing to tell the public or fellow journalists anything about what he has told Fitzgerald or a grand jury.
That he skates while Miller suffers is unbelievable and unforgivable.
In another twist, it's not clear whether the statute even applies to the Plame case, because she wasn't undercover when Novak wrote.
So, there's a strong chance that the only person who will ever serve time in this case is a journalist who never wrote a word about it.
At issue between Miller and federal Judge Thomas Hogan is a journalistic principle: You don't name a source to whom you have promised anonymity, unless the source waives that agreement. Too many journalists, especially in Washington, casually hand out this promise like dinner mints. But the principle is sound. Most states have affirmed some form of journalist-source "privilege." But the federal government has no such "shield" law. It should.
The judge had no patience with Miller's stance that her refusal to testify was an act of conscience. He framed the situation as an example of media arrogance. He denied a request for house arrest, even though the D.C. jail is so crowded Miller had to be sent to that Virginia cell.
This confusing case has divided journalists. Some think the paper and Miller are crazy to protect a possibly criminal leaker; others think Time was unforgivably craven for submitting Cooper's notes to the grand jury.
This case is a lousy example, but the public does have a strong interest in preserving a limited journalistic privilege. Without the protection of anonymity, sources with information that could expose the next Watergate, the next City Hall scandal, the next Enron, might never come forward.
The problem in the Plame case is that some sources at issue are not righteous whistle-blowers. Their vicious leaking is the alleged crime.
Miller and the Times faced a difficult choice. Some wise journalists applaud their stand; others don't. But let's be clear: The choice wasn't between right and wrong, lawfulness and arrogance. It was between two goods - Plame's rights and the public's right to know. In the real world, the hardest cases are the ones where valid values clash.
Wise or not, Miller's choice of civil disobedience, with acceptance of the consequences, was an act of principle, not arrogance. A distressing aspect of this surreal drama is that the judge did not seem to get that.
