Tour in Iraq inspires re-enactor
PINE TWP, Mercer County - As an Iraq War veteran, Jon Baker has witnessed history.
As a re-enactor - or living historian - the Pine Township resident must form a link between past and present, truth and performance, as he applies real-life experience to depictions of wartime.
Spending time as a military policeman in Baghdad last year helped Baker understand how a soldier thinks and feels while apart from his family and faced with danger. Baker said the Baghdad experience will carry over to his portrayal of soldiers in all time periods, since serving in Iraq allowed him to understand the realities of war and a soldier's life.
"It's difficult to describe what you read in peoples' memoirs. You could sit down and read the work of Sgt. Lamb, who was a British soldier during the Revolutionary War. He can describe all of the horrors he went through, but if you haven't actually experienced that, it's hard to imagine - even if you have a vivid imagination. It's hard to imagine the bloodshed on a large scale.
"We have video footage from Vietnam, from World War II, even Iraq, but it gets cut," he said.
By participating in living history demonstrations, Baker said he can also educate the public about the day-to-day aspects of wartime that otherwise are forgotten - from the French and Indian War to military action in Iraq.
"In the past, you could probably sit down and count out actual skirmishes (over the course of a war)," Baker said, explaining that throughout history a large part of a soldier's life was spent on tedious day-to-day tasks instead of the highly publicized battles. During re-enactments, Baker said he tries to feature those portions of a soldier's time that is not spent in battle.
"When people come to a re-enactment, we hope they didn't come just to see the two sides march up to each other and shoot muskets. We hope they will walk through the camps and learn about the actual lifestyle.
"Come down. Sit in my camp. This is the way we made coffee," he said of the small details that make re-enactments seem authentic.
"People don't think about how much time was actually spent in camp cleaning rifles, shaving. It seems like we're going from encounter to encounter in Iraq, which is not necessarily the case. Not everybody's doing that," Baker said, explaining that even during his Iraq experience the publicity focused on more sensational incidents.
"We'd been training Iraqi police for six months," he said of the U.S. Army Reserve 402nd Quartermaster Battalion based in New Castle, which served in Baghdad from May to December of last year. "The proportion of coverage (of our efforts) was 3-inch blocks (of text) versus 12-by-24-inch pages with photos (about violent action)."
David Armour of Grove City, who for 35 years participated in the management of three historic sites in Mackinac Island, Mich., agrees that real-life experience can influence how the past is perceived and portrayed.
During his career, Armour was involved in hiring full-time re-enactors, called interpreters, as well as a number of part-time people who would stage temporary encampments and interact with the public.
"We have found that people who have been in the military and then are functioning as interpreters do bring to that interpretive re-enactment experience a background that other people don't have. It's very true that the more background life experiences you have, you're better able to understand and interpret the past.
"If (the re-enactor) has been involved with functioning with an Army situation - with the discipline and the training and difficulties
-
just that would bring him insights into what our Civil War soldier's life was like, because most of that was not in combat," Armour said. "Most of it was day-to-day routine drill, training and so on. Hurry up and wait, then that uncertainty of what's happening to your life. Your officers control you and send you here and there, and you just obey."
David Dixon, a professor of history at Slippery Rock University, also draws a connection between past and present, real and re-enacted.
"I do feel that an experience in a wartime environment will shape your attitudes, that it will modify your belief systems, your world view. And that seems to be something that at least some researchers believe is a constant," Dixon said.
"I do think that it can make you have a better understanding of what soldiers from the past may have felt, may have thought, may have been exposed to," he added.
Dixon also pointed out the concept of unity that is important to troops, as well as living historians.
"Here's what researchers have come up with regarding universal impact that has transcended time for soldiers," Dixon said. "Soldiers initially ... join out of a spirit of patriotic fervor. ... Once in a combat zone, those kinds of sentiments seem to dissipate very quickly, then they take on the role of what real professional soldiers are supposed to feel. They fight not for the cause, but they fight for each other. Bonding takes place between men and women in a combat environment. ... What becomes more important for them is the person next to them in the ranks, not the cause.
"If you look at these organized military re-enactors units, there's a considerable bond that develops between those people as well."
Although he currently offers living history speaking and re-enactment services to schools and other groups, Baker hopes to expand that type of bond by eventually forming a nonprofit group of living historians that would be better equipped to cover all periods of history, including the present.
Baker, who is now completing a bachelor's degree in community ministry at Geneva College, plans to pursue a master's degree at the Pittsburgh Theological Seminary after graduating in January. With these skills, he hopes to further explore the military mindset of past and present.
"I see myself at least being a chaplain in the military as well as a chaplain for re-enactors," said Baker, whose college thesis project deals with those concepts.
Some of Baker's military uniforms and other items can be seen in a window display at the Grove City Historical Society on College Avenue.
'When people come to a re-enactment, we hope they didn't come just to see the two sides march up to each other and shoot muskets. We hope they will walk through the camps and learn about the actual lifestyle.'
John Baker
history re-enactor
