BUTLER SCHOOL BOARD
Republican voters in the Butler School District on May 21 will select four nominees for school board from five candidates, who are Al Vavro, John Conrad, Neil Convery, David Korn and Arthur Haag. The four candidates on the Democratic ballot will move on to the November ballot.
All candidates are cross-filed, except for Convery and Conrad, who appear only on the GOP ballot, and Charles Tanner, who only appears on the Democratic ballot.
QUESTION: When it comes to protecting students, how far should school boards go in spending on security measures? For instance, would you consider replacing all glass with bulletproof glass?
VAVRO: It is critical for school boards to continue supporting the implementation and enforcement of reasonable and prudent security procedures. Schools are not designed nor intended to be secured fortresses. Raising safety level concerns beyond reason could undermine the students’ learning environment. Since it is a limited deterrent, replacing all glass with bulletproof glass would not be cost-effective. Safety efforts should focus on holistic (universal) security applications that prevent intruders from gaining access to schools.
CONRAD: School boards need to act in accordance to the threat. I believe we did that when we voted to arm our school police on Dec. 10, 2012, four days BEFORE the Newtown school shooting. BASD had always been on the forefront on security. We were one of the first to use metal detectors. Again, we were one of the first to use metal detectors in the elementary schools. And then again, we were one of the first to have armed school police in every building.
There may be a time when bulletproof glass may be necessary, but not yet.
HAAG: As a parent there is no price we would not pay to protect our kids. Children must feel safe going to school and parents must feel safe sending them. Taxpayers know there is a limit to what they can afford. We need a compromise based on reality. As all schools struggle today to decide what is enough there are nine members on the Board representing and protecting the entire community.
CONVERY: The safety of our children is of utmost importance. The school board must consider each new proposal in detail. We must provide a safe learning environment, but should also pursue measures that do not interfere with education or cause undue fear. From the minute the child steps onto the bus, families must have confidence that all efforts are being made to keep their child out of harm’s way.
KORN: Any and all measures should be considered for the safety of schools. Secured entrances with guards and cameras along with little or no glass, if possible, may be necessary. Updates to existing facilities need to be evaluated yearly.
QUESTION: What can the school board do to help students score higher on standardized tests? For example, more tutors? Focusing the curriculum toward better scoring on these tests?
VAVRO: The board’s responsibility is to provide the necessary resources as justified by the administrative team to improve standardized test scores. Recommendations regarding curriculum, instruction and assessment are provided for the board’s consideration by the district’s curriculum council.
In these difficult economic times, the collaborative efforts of the board and administration must first make the most efficient and effective use of the current staff to meet our students’ educational needs before any additional staffing is considered.
CONRAD: Many theories come and go as to how to better teach the needed skills. We need to focus on researched methods that are KNOWN to work. We have already focused curriculum to the state goals and implemented more tutors. We also need to engage more parents in the education of their children. In other words, we need to educate parents to better support their children.
HAAG: The Keystone Exams (The Graduation Exam) are new tests designed to align with the national standards. All new tests have a learning curve for both the teacher and the student. Our curriculum committees must provide support for our teachers to maximize their students’ knowledge and test taking skills. We must integrate the new test materials into all our classrooms. This will introduce the children to this new material and make them confident and better test takers.
CONVERY: The board must help create a stronger partnership between the classroom and the home and enrich the curriculum to its fullest. The schools should move away from the factory model of education toward meeting the needs and learning styles of each individual child. Additionally, the board should carefully consider improving the district’s technological capabilities to enhance the efforts in the classroom. The board should help each school find tutors and other resources through community efforts, without additional costs to the school district.
KORN: School curriculums are based on state standards, that can be viewed at www.education.state.pa.us/ It is the intention of these standards to have curriculum that meets the requirements for graduation. When there is a state curriculum, and all schools use the same texts and teachers the same methods there will be equity for success.
QUESTION: With school districts facing deficits, are you more likely to cut spending or to raise taxes to balance the budget? Should districts think harder about closing schools?
VAVRO: Difficult decisions are ongoing regarding budget deficits. The board in collaboration with the administrative team must continue to prioritize and evaluate all nonessential spending. A comprehensive building facilities study is in progress and will project the cost effectiveness of school closings. In addition, the reconfiguration of the K-12 program could be explored as a cost-saving measure. Raising taxes should be a last resort in meeting the core educational needs of our students.
CONRAD: I recognize that there are other districts that spend many millions of dollars with the belief that they want the best — no matter the cost. There are others who want the cheapest — without regard to the cost of deprived student opportunities. The many taxpayers and parents I have talked to want the best education that the Butler Area can afford. I fully support this concept even though it may mean maximizing efficiency by closing schools, and possibly some tax increases to replace lost state and federal funding.
HAAG: Parents don’t want to lose their neighborhood schools; it’s part of their community’s identity. Any plans to shut down schools must involve the community to minimize the impact. The disruption to everyday life will be profound both emotionally and financially. The Center Avenue School had hidden consequences and only by careful planning and research was the mishap avoided. Short-term fixes can have long-term consequences, so careful planning is necessary.
CONVERY: I disagree with the idea of continually asking the taxpayers in this district, year after year, to pay increased taxes. I will focus this conversation on what spending is and is not essential in our stewardship of providing our children with the best education possible. Although we might not like it, regardless of the industry, there is most often someone out there doing more with less, I believe that is our reality moving forward.
KORN: The job of the school board is to remain fiscally responsible to the community. Spending cuts should be determined by cost benefit/value of programs. Closing schools hurts the local neighborhood and would be a last resort unless the school is found to be unsound and unsafe. Decisions are always made with the best interest for the students.
