Site last updated: Saturday, November 21, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Sheetz zoning request tabled until April 1

Larger store proposed

BUTLER TWP — Developers are back before the township seeking to build a new, bigger Sheetz convenience store at Center and Morton avenues.

The township commissioners Monday night heard a zoning request that would etch out a 3½-acre lot at that site, and allow commercial buildings to be constructed on it.

After hearing about the proposed zoning changes, they tabled a decision until April 1.

The developers want to build a 6,500-square-foot convenience store with six multi-gas pump dispensers, a car wash and a drive through food facility. The proposed store is catty-cornered to the 3,774-square-foot Sheetz that the Altoona-based convenience store company now leases and developers described as outdated.

If the rezoning is approved, Sheetz still would need to go through the land development process before construction could start.

Before the commissioners now is only the zoning change request.

The entire 32 acres is zoned agricultural with an institutional overlay. This means the entire property can be used for farming or public use purposes, such as a hospital.

In the revised plan, general commercial structures also could be built only on the newly created lot.

The zoning change technically would be granted to Butler County, owner of the property.

According to the county planning department, Sheetz is leasing the lot for $75,000 a year, contingent on township zoning change. The 15-year lease starts when all approvals and permits are granted. When it ends, Sheetz will have the option to renew the lease in five-year increments.

If the building is constructed, the property will no longer be tax exempt, and Sheetz will pick up the property tax bill.

Planners last fall withdrew a similar request for rezoning after residents expressed concerns about noise, light and commotion especially in reference to direction of the building’s front.

James McCormick told the commissioners that since then developers made a “good faith effort” to redesign the plan to address those concerns.

Specifically, he said, the proposed lot size was increased a half acre so the building could be “rotated 90 degrees” so it no longer fronts Center Avenue. The developers also relocated the car wash to the rear of the lot, moved a driveway and included landscape buffering around the proposal’s perimeter.

Still, a handful of residents at Monday’s meeting had concerns, specifically for the safety of children in the neighborhood.

“That’s a lot of cars going through a quiet neighborhood,” said Stephen Smith of Crestview Drive. “I’m not convinced this will be any good at all for our community or our neighborhood.”

The vote to table the zoning request passed 3-1 with commissioner George Shockey absent. Commissioner Joseph A. Wiest said he cast the lone vote against delaying the decision because he said the board already has enough information, and he was prepared to vote in favor.

Although developers during the meeting called the Sheetz plan a “multimillion” dollar investment in the community, they afterward refused to identify its budget. They also refused to say what type of timeline they had in mind to begin construction.

However, they said if the project receives all needed approvals, construction will take about five months to complete.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS