Site last updated: Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

The White House made big mistakes before the storm

By CARL LEUBSDORF

In picking John G. Roberts Jr. for chief justice less than 36 hours after the death of William Rehnquist, President Bush showed his ability to act swiftly and decisively at crucial moments.

His demonstration of that aspect of presidential leadership marked a sharp contrast with his slow assumption of command and responsibility in meeting the challenges of Hurricane Katrina.

That generated a spate of negative stories likely to sap further his diminished job-approval standing. But history is likely to show that Bush’s real failure in decision-making occurred in the years leading up to Hurricane Katrina.

Though presidential aides have touted his skills as the nation’s first president with an MBA degree, the way he has allocated scarce fiscal resources, selected key personnel and structured the government’s crisis machinery made last week’s crisis almost inevitable.

Resources:

The White House consistently rejected efforts by local politicians and the Corps of Engineers for funds to strengthen flood control and prevention efforts in the New Orleans area.

While this may indicate their lack of political clout, it also may reflect a feeling that those warning of disaster were crying “wolf,” since decades of such alarms had never materialized.

But it mainly reflects the result of a battle for fiscal and human resources by a government increasingly stretched thin. One factor is the heavy demand of wars in Iraq and Afghanistan both in financial and human terms, because of the heavy reliance on National Guard troops.

Personnel:

Bush’s first head of the Federal Emergency Management Agency and his former chief of staff, Joe Allbaugh, was an experienced hand at state governmental issues with real clout at the White House. His successor, lawyer Michael Brown, is neither.

The first secretary of homeland security, former Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Ridge, was the experienced executive of a major state, and he had trouble managing the massive new department. His successor, Michael Chertoff, is neither and is unequipped to run one of the biggest federal bureaucracies.

Things might have moved a lot more quickly if a Rudy Giuliani had been in charge.

Structure:

After decades in which federal responsibility for disaster relief was scattered, it was centralized in FEMA during the Carter administration. President Bill Clinton brought in James Lee Witt, who held a similar job in Arkansas and had both standing and instant access to the White House.

When FEMA was combined into Homeland Security, it lost both standing and focus. The emphasis was shifted to combating terrorism. And in July, FEMA lost its role of working with states and localities to plan for disasters.

Fixing these errors will come too late to prevent the mess in dealing with this crisis but may be able to prevent one the next time.

Still, much of Bush’s post-hurricane grade may depend on whether he takes decisive steps to deal with the aftermath.

It’s not just providing billions of dollars and needed personnel.

His administration needs to come up with imaginative ways to cope with the economic impact on the thousands of New Orleanians who have neither homes nor jobs. Wal-Mart set a stand-

ard by offering its employees jobs in their new locations. Clinton has suggested that the government offer incentives to other companies to do that.

Meanwhile, Bush needs to review his entire economic plan in light of the possibility that the initial $10 billion is only the start — and this at a time when the collapse of economic activity in the Gulf South will reduce revenues for a budget already in deficit.

Senate leaders made a good decision in delaying this week’s scheduled debate on repealing estate taxes. The measure ought to be dropped entirely. If anything, it may be time for the administration and Congress to consider ways to raise the billions that the disaster will require.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS