Site last updated: Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Judge says auctions to go on

But net proceeds will be frozen

A judge Thursday refused to stop auctions scheduled to liquidate the assets of a Brady Township businessman who was murdered by his own son.

However, net proceeds from the sales will be frozen.

The first in a 7- or 8-part series of auctions at the 571 West Liberty Road estate of murder victims Kenneth and Celeste Abbott is scheduled for Saturday.

Investigators found the mutilated, burned remains of Kenneth Abbott, 65, and his wife, Celeste Abbott, 55, scattered about that property in the summer of 2011.

Kenneth Abbott’s son and greatest heir, 42-year-old Colin Abbott of New Jersey, earlier this year pleaded no contest to murdering the couple, and now he is serving 35 to 80 years in prison.

Attorney H. Craig Hinkle, representing Colin Abbott, on Thursday unsuccessfully asked Butler County Judge S. Michael Yeager to preserve the assets by putting a hold on the sales.

“I’m not going to stay the auctions,” Yeager said, noting that Colin Abbott this winter was given the opportunity to pick and set aside items from the $4 million estate that he might want. Colin Abbott did not respond to the court.

Still, prompted by Colin Abbott’s request, Yeager ordered the net proceeds from auctions be put into an escrow account until further court order.

Butler lawyer Tom King, representing the estate, argued that Colin Abbott has no right to make any requests of the court. Although Colin Abbott was named as the main beneficiary to his father’s $4 million estate, King’s firm is arguing to keep him from getting any of his father’s assets under the state’s Slayer’s Act. That law says a person cannot benefit from a death he caused.

Colin Abbott pleaded no contest to two counts of third-degree murder, and King is arguing that a no contest plea is weighed as a guilty plea in these cases.

“Colin Abbott has no standing; he’s a murderer,” King said. “He is dead in the eyes of the law as far as his father’s assets are concerned.”

However, Hinkle in court documents argued that Colin Abbott’s criminal case is active because he is appealing to the state’s Superior Court. Colin Abbott is asking the appellate court to toss out his plea deal and grant him a trial.

Additionally, the documents allege that “Colin Abbott has made no indication or admission of guilt. No court or jury has entered a guilty verdict against Colin Abbott.” Therefore, Colin Abbott’s court documents allege that his father’s assets still are his property legally. Although a no contest plea is given the weight of a guilty plea, it does not require a defendant acknowledge his guilt.

Hinkle in court argued that Colin Abbott has standing in case relevant to his father’s assets until a judge determines that he does not have standing. And the courts have “some duty to protect Colin Abbott’s rights until he has no rights.”

Yeager said he will hear arguments about the Slayer’s Act in court and issue a ruling on that issue in July.

Meantime, the auction on Saturday will offer for sale tractors, farm and lawn equipment.

Later sales will offer cars, boats, collectibles, toys and household items accrued by Kenneth Abbott.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS