OTHER VOICES
The appropriation of $62 billion by Congress to pay for disaster relief in the wake of Hurricane Katrina means that all Americans are pitching in to pay for this painful recovery. President Bush's speech on Thursday night ensures that this will be only the first installment in a rebuilding effort of unprecedented scale. The principle behind this generous impulse is that natural disasters are everyone's business. If the pain can't be distributed evenly, the expense can be. Now it's time for Congress to realize that the same principle should apply to insurance covering major disasters.
As hurricanes like Katrina become more frequent and destructive, a catastrophe-insurance program modeled on flood insurance should become a priority for lawmakers before the next big disaster strikes.
According to the Insurance Information Institute, Congress created the National Flood Insurance Program in 1968 in response to "the rising cost of taxpayer-funded disaster relief for flood victims and the increasing amount of damage caused by floods."
Substitute the words hurricane or windstorm for flood in the preceding sentence, and you have a perfect description of today's situation with windstorm and hurricane insurance. The expense of Katrina is undeniable evidence of the rising cost of windstorms. Meanwhile, 2005's record hurricane season - along with the four hurricanes that hit Florida last year - should persuade the most hardened skeptic that we live in an era of heightened danger.
Before the flood-insurance program was created, government-backed relief in disastrous floods came from general revenues, in much the same manner as aid is provided to the victims of Katrina today. For taxpayers, the flood-insurance program makes more sense because the NFIP is self-supporting. Expenses and claims are paid through premiums collected for flood-insurance policies, not by the U.S. government.
Because policies are required of potential flood victims across the country, premiums remain relatively affordable. In 2004, according to the insurance institute, the average premium was $411 for coverage of $150,000. Compare that to the huge windstorm premiums paid by residents living in the most vulnerable parts of Florida, and the advantages of a comprehensive national program become clear.
Of course, no insurance program can cover all the expenses of a calamity of Katrina's magnitude. Extra relief will be needed because many potential victims will remain uninsured, and losses will exceed coverage when the level of destruction is so great. Still, the existence of an insurance program of national dimensions, ultimately underwritten by the government, becomes a significant mitigating factor.
Here's another advantage: Putting flood, windstorm and other catastrophic events into one package would minimize the possibility that disaster victims will be cheated by insurance companies. Already, the attorney general of Mississippi is suing five insurance companies for allegedly cheating policyholders by attributing Katrina's damage to a flood, thus avoiding responsibility for damage covered by windstorm policies.
Some will argue, no doubt, that most Americans aren't vulnerable to windstorm and hurricane damage, so they shouldn't be asked to pay for those who are at risk. This is the same argument used by some Floridians who believed they faced no risk from hurricanes ... until last year's storms cut across the state and damaged inland areas once considered "safe."
The facts don't support the argument either, according to the insurance institute: In 2003, a fairly typical year, homeowners' insurance losses from wind or hail damage accounted for 25 percent of all losses nationwide. This was exceeded only by the 33 percent of losses attributed to fire, lighting and debris removal - which is why the proposed new disaster insurance should cover all major catastrophes, not just hurricanes or floods.
- The Miami Herald
