Site last updated: Sunday, November 22, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Buffalo Creek a hot spot for trout

In an area with limited coldwater fishing opportunities, Buffalo Creek provides an important trout fishing resource. The specially regulated delayed-harvest area provides anglers eager to feel the tug of a trout on the line an outstanding option.

Buffalo Creek is formed in Butler County and flows through Armstrong County, joining with the Allegheny at Freeport. The Delayed Harvest, Artificial Lures Only project flows from the mouth of Little Buffalo Run 3.7 miles downstream to a point six-tenths of a mile above Route 4035 in Craigsville. It is located on the Butler/Armstrong county line.

Within the project waters, Buffalo Creek averages about 30 feet in width. It is typical of the streams of southwestern Pennsylvania in that earthen banks prevail. Much character is present within the stretch of water. This is due largely to the work done over the years by the Arrowhead Chapter of Trout Unlimited.

Current deflectors have been added to constrict the channel and to increase stream flows in that area. Major portions of soft-bottom stream bank have been stabilized to prevent further erosion. The Chapter works closely with the Fish and Boat Commission and conducts float stocking that keeps the trout well distributed throughout the nearly four miles of project area.

Mark Transue first introduced me to Buffalo Creek many years ago. Since that time, I've made it a point to learn a bit more about the stream each year, and Transue has helped me with that process.

The lower end of the special regulations water can be reached by taking Bottom Creek Road off of Route 4035, which is accessed just west of Worthington.

The project water begins soon after you get on Bottom Creek Road. As you head upstream, the road rises along the hill a bit away from the creek. The creek flows through a steep valley in this stretch. Anglers can access this portion of Buffalo Creek by parking along one of two pulloffs and hiking down the hill to the creek.

Though not remote by any means, it does take some effort to reach this stretch, which contains a nice mix of deeper holes, runs and riffles.

A strategy I've used in the past is to park at the downstream pulloff, fish up to the area of the Railroad Bridge, then hike to the second pulloff and walk the road back to my vehicle.

Continuing on Bottom Creek Road, you will intersect with Hindman Hill Road. Make a left and you'll soon intersect with Route 3013, a paved road that runs along the next section of Buffalo Creek. A left will take you to Nichola Bridge. There is a parking area there, and some nice pools located downstream.

Make a right, and you will parallel the creek for the next major portion of project water. There is easy access here, with several streamside pulloffs present. Much of the stabilization and stream improvement work was done along this portion of stream.

Route 3013 runs along the creek up to the area know as the Log House. To stay with the stream, make a left onto Fennelton Road. Continue along Fennelton Road, and then make another left on Morrow Road, which crosses Buffalo Creek at the McMillian Bridge, the uppermost access area. A good pool is located at the bridge.

Deflectors have been placed in the creek upstream of the bridge. The project area ends where Little Buffalo Run enters the creek.

You can access Buffalo Creek not only from Worthington, but also by taking route 3013 off of Route 422 near the M&M Limestone Quarry or by taking County Line Road, again off of Route 422. Make a right onto Morrow Road off of County Line Road to reach the McMillian Bridge.

In terms of presentations, Buffalo Creek, is like most southwestern Pennsylvania trout streams during the early spring. Fly fishers score well by dead-drifting patterns like the Woolly Bugger, especially if the water is up a bit and off color. Lower, clearer conditions might call for nymph patterns, such as the Hare's Ear or muskrat nymph.

Trout also will chase hardware early in the year, especially later in the day during warm, sunny conditions. I've had excellent success with spoons and spinners. Fish spinners and spoons by quartering them upstream, allowing them to sweep down with the current during the retrieve.

Typically, Buffalo Creek receives its preseason stocking early in March, if conditions permit. Also, often there is a carryover of trout stocked during the previous fall. Nice weekends will see plenty of attention before the mid-April season opener. Conditions during the week, or after the statewide opener, are much less crowded.

Jeff Knapp is an outdoors columnist for the Butler Eagle.

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS