Site last updated: Monday, November 16, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Equine group founder cleared of trespassing

SLIPPERY ROCK — The operator of a Butler County horse rescue group was cleared Wednesday of a trespass charge stemming from an animal cruelty investigation this year.

While citing “conflicting” and”confusing” testimony at a summary trial, District Judge Tim Shaffer dismissed the case against Pam Vivirito, founder of Cabot-based Equine Angels Rescue.

State police in April cited Vivirito a month after she and another member of her group removed six horses from Brian Arendosh’s farm on Cherry Road in Fairview Township.

Vivirito said she took the action March 21 because she believed the horses had been neglected.

Police subsequently charged Arendosh with animal cruelty, alleging those horses lacked adequate food, water, shelter and veterinary care.

But Arendosh, a day after he voluntarily surrendered his horses to Vivirito, contacted police to complain that she had come onto his property without permission.

He testified Wednesday that when he returned home from work March 21 he spotted two vehicles — a state police cruiser and a pickup truck — in front of a trailer where his daughter lives on his farm.

A 400-foot driveway leads to that trailer home from Cherry Road.

Arendosh said he later learned that Vivirito and her associate, Stacy McCall, had driven there in the truck. A short time later, Trooper Robert Downs had arrived in response to a call Vivirito made to police.

Downs testified that he went to the farm after Vivirito contacted Trooper Shawn King, the state police animal control officer, to complain of finding neglected horses there.

During her call to King, Vivirito had sent by cell phone several photographs allegedly attesting to the bad condition of the horses, according to testimony.

“She could not have taken the photos without being on my property,” Arendosh told Downs, who prosecuted the case at Wednesday’s summary trial.

However, on cross-examination by Vivirito’s attorney, John Haller, Arendosh admitted he did not know who took the photographs.

“Did you see (Vivirito) take the pictures?” Haller asked.

“No,” Arendosh replied. He acknowledged he did not see anyone take any photographs on his property that day.

But he also referred to a conversation he had with Vivirito while she was there. She expressed concern over how his horses were being fed.

“She said I was not adding enough fat to their feed,” he told Haller. “She particularly referred to a thoroughbred in my barn.”

That barn is in a fenced-in pasture behind his daughter’s trailer. He said to get to the barn Vivirito would have to go through a gate in the fence.

“How could she have known about (the thoroughbred) if she had not been in my barn?” Arendosh asked.

However, he again conceded to Haller that he did not see Vivirito or anyone else in his barn that day.

During the defense case, Vivirito testified that she was never in Arendosh’s barn. She also denied taking any photographs.

“Do you know who did?” Haller asked his client.

“No,” she replied.

She claimed she received the photographs “from someone else” and that she later sent them to King.

Vivirito, when questioned by Downs, said that representatives of the county’s humane society and “passers-by” had previously taken and sent to her photographs of Arendosh’s farm and horses.

“I got those photos the night before (the visit),” she said.

McCall, the only other defense witness, seemed to corroborate Vivirito’s testimony. She said that neither she nor Vivirito took any photographs or went into Arendosh’s barn that day.

Following more than an hour of testimony, Shaffer dismissed the trespass charge.

“The testimony was certainly conflicting,” he said, “and I feel there’s a lot more here than meets the eye. But I find that the commonwealth has not sustained its proof.”

Before recessing the proceedings, Shaffer complimented the presentations of both sides in the case, although acknowledging, “It was confusing.”

Meanwhile, Arendosh will be back in court July 1, as the defendant at his summary trial on 36 counts of animal cruelty. Police filed those charges April 8 following their investigation prompted by Vivirito’s visit.

He disputes the charges and maintains that his horses were “well cared for.”

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS