Site last updated: Saturday, November 21, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Abbott's attorney asks judge to be replaced

An attorney for convicted killer Colin Abbott is looking to be replaced.

Based on the “prior history of this case” and allegations Abbott has raised about her in his request to withdraw from his plea arrangement, defense attorney Wendy Williams of Pittsburgh on Tuesday asked the courts to appoint him a new lawyer.

Abbott, a 43-year-old New Jersey man, pleaded no contest to killing his father and stepmother at their Brady Township estate in June 2011.

Prosecutors believe Abbott killed Kenneth Abbott, 65, and Celeste Abbott, 55, to cover up a mortgage scheme he had engaged his wealthy father in, erase $2 million in bad debt to his father and to inherit the couple’s $4 million estate. Investigators found the couple’s burned remains at their home on July 13, 2011.

The county district attorney’s office initially sought two counts of first-degree murder and the death penalty. But as part of a plea arrangement, Abbott on Feb. 26 pleaded no contest to two counts of third degree murder. A day later, the defendant was sentenced to serve 35 to 80 years in prison.

But within a week, Abbott handwrote a request to the judge asking to withdraw from his plea arrangement and have a trial.

Abbott alleged that unanswered evidence questions, a deteriorating relationship with Williams and a one-day deadline to make a decision forced him to enter a plea arrangement that he’s dissatisfied with now.

According to the five-page request he wrote to the judge, the defendant alleged the level of pressure applied behind the scenes amounted to the type of “manifest injustice” that should negate his decision.

Butler County Judge William Shaffer is set to hear the issue Thursday.

Williams, in her request to the judge Monday, asserts that it would be a conflict of interest for her to represent Abbott at this hearing or any future hearings.

Williams claims she spent hours with the defendant on the day of the plea and sentencing and he never mentioned wanting to withdraw his plea.

Williams’ request said days after the fact, the defendant’s mother contacted her saying Abbott wanted to withdraw his plea. It alleges Williams asked Abbott’s mother to tell the defendant to call her. However, Williams alleges the defendant did not communicate with her until after he had already filed his request to withdraw his plea.

Williams did not return a telephone message seeking comment. Assistant District Attorney Ben Simon, who prosecuted the case, declined to comment.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS