Suit filed in fatal accident
A North Washington man and his employer are being sued for negligence and wrongful death in connection with a fatal accident last year on Route 422 in Muddy Creek Township.
Michael Lindsay, 67; Lindy Paving, and its subsidiary, PNM Trucking, face six counts in the lawsuit.
The parents of the 29-year-old man who died in the accident, Randy and Jo Greenwood of Belle Vernon in Westmoreland County, filed the lawsuit July 1 in Butler County Court on behalf of their son's estate and themselves.
They want a jury trial.
Attorney Cynthia Danel of the Pittsburgh firm Edgar Snyder & Associates, who represents the Greenwoods, said the victim's family was shattered by his death.
“The Greenwoods are devastated beyond belief,” Danel said.
According to Butler state police, Allan Mark Greenwood died July 17, 2012, after a triaxle truck driven by Lindsay struck a 105-foot utility pole Greenwood was positioning for removal off the highway.
An earlier traffic accident resulted in a 6-foot section of the 6,400-pound pole being sheared off.
The pole, which was larger than the standard size, was going to be used for a PennDOT wireless communication system project in Mercer County,
A Bruce & Merrilees Electric Co. crew was hauling the pole from a gravel parking lot on the south side of the highway using a dump truck and hitch.
Police report the dump truck driven by Phae D. Cutchall III, 51, of New Castle was making a wide left turn onto the highway when a car driven by David Evans, 64, of Evans City hit the pole.
The 6-foot piece of the pole broke off, staying attached to the truck. The end of the pole landed on the road.
“It's an unusual situation,” Danel said.
Greenwood, a lineman for Bruce & Merrilees, was in the process of pulling the pole off the road using a crane.
“He was lashing it with a chain,” Danel said.
Police report the truck driven by Lindsay was in a line of traffic going around the pole by traveling on the side of the road when it hit or ran over the pole, causing the other end to swing around and hit Greenwood in the head.
“It whipped around and hit him,” Danel said.
Greenwood, who suffered a massive head injury, was pronounced dead at the scene.
Danel said the work crew stopped traffic along the highway to safely clear the pole, but motorists eventually resumed traveling on their own volition.
According to Danel, Lindsay should have known his truck would not clear the pole by going onto the berm.
Lindsay could not be reached for comment. There is no phone listing under his name.
A company representative for Lindy Paving could not be reached for comment.
A voice-mail message left for attorney Mark Caloyer of the Pittsburgh firm Pietragallo, Gordon, Alfano, Bosick & Raspanti, who represents the defendants, was not returned.
Cutchall was cited for failing to yield the right of way to oncoming traffic.
Lindsay was not cited for any violation. Police reported his truck was gong no faster than 5 mph when it made contact with the pole.
At the time, police were reviewing whether to file other charges.
Although Lindsay did not remain at the scene following the accident, he did contact police the next day, saying he was unaware of what happened until learning about it through media accounts.
But Danel said Lindsay's account doesn't hold up under scrutiny.
“He knew what happened,” she said.
Danel said Lindsay only contacted police after he knew they inquired about any Lindy Paving trucks being at the scene of the accident.
Danel said there was no negligence on the part of Greenwood's employer, saying the pole could not have been moved by a large flatbed since it was being taken along dirt roads.
She said the only concern listed by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration about the process was that the company could have had more flag men.
According to Danel, Bruce & Merrilees could not be sued due to workers' compensation guidelines, which stipulate the company pays for treatment of any work-related injuries, but is not held liable otherwise.
“You're not entitled to sue the employer,” she said.
Danel said no blame lies with Evans either regarding the second impact.
Danel said the timing of Lindsay's pass-through could not have been worse.
“Another five seconds and none of this would have happened,” she said.
Along with document costs, such as funeral expenses, the Greenwoods are seeking their son's lost wages.
Their son lived with them, and Danel said he made a major financial contribution to his parents.
She said a monetary amount could not be attached to intangible losses listed in the complaint, including loss of life's pleasures.
Danel said Greenwood's family, including his sister and niece, have not recovered from the tragedy.
“Just inconsolable,” Danel said.
Randy Greenwood also works for Bruce & Merrilees.
“He hasn't been to work since,” Danel said.
And Jo Greenwood has had a daily stop since the accident a year ago.
“The mother visits the cemetery every day,” Danel said.
