Accusers testify at abuse hearing
A former Butler man accused of 170 sex-offense counts fondled and molested two girls for years, according to the accusers’ testimony.
The alleged victims, now young women, testified Monday at a preliminary hearing that Thomas W. Lehnerd, 50, began sexually abusing them when they were 4 or 5 years old.
“There are so many incidents to recall,” one of the accusers told prosecutor Richard Bosco, a Butler County assistant district attorney.
District Judge Pete Shaffer ordered Lehnerd of Deming, N.M., held for trial on all charges Butler police filed against him in January.
He is charged with involuntary deviate sexual intercourse, 70 counts of aggravated indecent assault, 95 counts of indecent assault, and two counts each of child endangerment and corruption of minors.
Married and the father of three grown children, the defendant remains in the Butler County Prison on $1 million bail.
Both accusers, who are in their early 20s, testified that Lehnerd assaulted them in Oakland Township and Butler, where he used to live.
The Butler Eagle is not identifying the women due to the nature of the crimes.
The suspected abuse started in 1993 and continued until 2008, police said in charging documents.
Lehnerd lived in Butler County most of his life, authorities said, before moving about three years ago to Deming, a city in southwestern New Mexico about 30 miles north of the Mexican border.
The younger of the two alleged victims appeared to have a better memory of the suspected abuse.
“He rubbed his hands all over my body,” she said.
Lehnerd, she testified groped and fondled her, and rubbed his genitals against her body.
“It felt icky,” she said, when asked to recall how it felt at that time.
She said he performed a sex act on her when she was between 10 and 12.
Both accusers testified that the defendant would force them to touch his genitals.
The older of the women claimed the defendant “sexually abused” her for years. But she seemed to have a difficult time recalling specific assaults.
The two women on cross-examination by Lehnerd’s attorney, public defender Terri Schultz, acknowledged some lapses in memory brought on by the years that have passed.
“I don’t have a good compass as far as dates and times,” the younger accuser said.
Both alleged victims claimed they kept their silence for so long in part because they didn’t understand what was happening to them.
“Didn’t you ever report it to your mother?” Schultz asked the younger woman.
“Absolutely not,” the accuser replied. “I didn’t have the words to tell my mother.”
But that same woman came forward in December 2011, reporting the alleged abuse to a victim’s advocate agency in her current home, not in Pennsylvania.
Law enforcement authorities in that state interviewed her in May 2012. Soon after, Butler police received a copy of that audiotaped interview.
In July 2012, she traveled to Butler where police Detective Sgt. John Johnson interviewed her.
Several months later, a second woman appeared at city police station, accusing Lehnerd of abusing her, too.
Shaffer on Jan. 28 issued police an arrest warrant for Lehnerd. The next day, Luna County sheriff’s deputies in New Mexico served that warrant for Butler police and arrested the suspect at his home.
He eventually waived extradition and was returned to Butler County on March 8.
Following the hearing, Schultz declined to discuss the accusers’ testimony or the charges against her client.
“All I’ll say is that he’s maintaining his innocence,” she said of Lehnerd.
