Site last updated: Saturday, November 21, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Man charged with theft

He allegedly stole money and drugs

BUTLER TWP — The recent theft of money and prescription drugs from the principal’s and nurse’s offices at two schools turned out to have been an inside job, authorities said.

A former substitute custodian for the Butler School District is accused of both crimes.

Butler Township police on Thursday charged David Lee Herold, 27, of Eau Claire with using his one-time position to pilfer the property at Meridian Elementary and Butler Intermediate schools last month.

Just three months on the job, the suspect March 11 took $40 that was in principal Tim Sissini’s office at the Meridian Elementary School, according to court documents.

That same day, he allegedly stole 23 Ritalin tablets from the nurse’s office at the elementary school. Police believe he also took a socket set from the custodian’s office there.

Three days later, documents said, Herold forced open three desks in the principal’s office at Butler Intermediate School and made off with a combined $200.

Also on March 14, he allegedly took 21 Ritalin tablets from the nurse’s office at the same school.

Investigators on March 28 interviewed Herold, who acknowledged having “abused Ritalin in the past,” but apparently he did not admit to either theft, a police affidavit said.

He claimed he has “an addiction to opiates but not heroin” and was “high” on March 14, the affidavit said; however, he could not recall anything much about that night or March 11.

Mike Strutt, Butler School District superintendent, said Herold was hired in December as a substitute custodian on an “as-needed basis.”

“He was removed from the substitutes’ list immediately upon (the district) learning of the charges,” Strutt said Friday.

Herold is charged with two misdemeanor counts each of theft and possession of a controlled substance. A preliminary hearing was not immediately scheduled.

The Butler Eagle could not reach Herold for comment.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS