Site last updated: Saturday, November 21, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Better with age

Butler Twp Police chief John Hays holds a old rifle the township owns worth 22,000 they are considering selling at the police station.
Old police rifles shoot up in price

BUTLER TWP — Like a fine wine, the potential price tag of two .223-caliber rifles owned by the township police may have gotten better with age.

Weapons similar to the Colt Armalite AR-15 Model 01 are selling among gun collectors on the Internet for up to $22,000 each.

The weapons, part of the department's armory since 1961, have gained in value without notice for decades.

They became a topic of discussion at a recent township commissioner's meeting when Mark Krenitsky of Meridian suggested the guns be sold.

“If they are just sitting there and we can sell them, we should sell them,” Krenitsky said. “Repurpose that money.”

The commissioners took no action on Krenitsky's comment, and township manager Ed Kirkwood said later, “At this given point in time, a census of the board of commissioners has not made a decision to retain the weapons or to dispose of them ... I would not be in favor of making a rash decision just to generate some money. The township has no cash flow problems at present.”

The weapons still are in excellent condition and work. Krenitsky and police Chief John Hays said the guns' serial numbers are considered “very low.”

The guns initially were designed to be fully automatic, but by removing a piece from the trigger, they now are semiautomatic. The township still have the removed pieces that can be reinstalled.

The fully automatic option is what gives this weapon it's potential value, said Jim Osche, manager at Sportsman Supply in Butler.

“They don't make them anymore (for civilian purchase),” said Osche, who said $20,000 would be “in the ballpark” on an appropriate value for the weapon as it was described to him. However, he has not see the weapons and therefore could not give a more exact estimate of value.

Officials, including Osche, said semiautomatic rifles appropriate for police use cost about $1,500.

Chief Hays said the Colts originally were used by officers when they escorted armored cars through the township, a practice that ended even before Hays was hired 17 years ago.

About a handful of years ago, following a series of school shootings in different parts of the country, the police department outfitted itself with new Smith & Wesson rifles and mandated training for every officer in the department. The rifles are “another tool” the department uses in addition to its duty handguns for patrol and special circumstances, like a standoff, Hays said.

For the most part, the department no longer uses the Colts.

“But we could,” said Hays. “These are basically the same as the new ones we have.”

Although Hays took no stand on if the weapons should stay or go, he said he did think that even if every rule was followed in selling the guns, they still could someday end up in the wrong hands.

“Just the idea of that worries me,” he said. “Especially the way things are in the world right now.”

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS