Site last updated: Sunday, November 22, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Pymatuning still good for walleyes

Arguably the state's top walleye lake, Pymatuning has undergone changes that affect its fisheries. Walleye fishing there is not the same as it once was, but quality sport remains available.

Having no closed season means it provides the first open water walleye fishing opportunities of the new spring.

It is suspected that alewife might be partly to blame for poor year classes of young walleyes the past few years. It's been documented that alewife, an open water baitfish of the herring family, not only feed directly on young walleye, but that they compete with them for food sources that tend to be limited in the early spring.

Each year, the Fish and Boat Commission stocks millions of walleye fry in to Pymatuning to supplement what natural reproduction that takes place. Hence, the dynamics of the lake's walleye population in recent years has been one of fewer but larger walleyes.

The lake also took a hit last summer when a stretch of extremely hot weather prevailed. Elevated water temperatures were blamed for a fish kill that included walleyes, mostly larger adults.

Though the true magnitude of the kill is not known, the commission confirmed that some adult walleyes were lost. I spoke with a biologist right after he had scoped out the lake during the heat wave. They counted 13 floating walleyes that day.

During a young-of-the-year walleye survey conducted in the fall, however, many large walleyes were spotted. Also, it appears a fairly good year class of fish of legal size should be entering the fishery this year.

Last season, I caught and released many sub-legals in the 13-inch range, and heard similar reports from other anglers, though fish should be over 15 inches this year.

Coupled with the remnants of the older year classes the lake holds, there should be enough walleyes to make things interesting this year.

Successful fishing right after ice out means being versatile The need for angler versatility comes from the fact the fish will be on the move from the deeper wintering areas to spawning areas. Spawning usually gets going in early April.

This time of year it's not usual to hear of fish being caught in two feet of water, as well as ones taken in depths of 22 feet.

Female walleyes don't seem to spend much time in the shallows, so it's not surprising that some of the larger fish are taken in deeper water throughout the early spring.

Here is a look at three solid patterns for taking Pymatuning's walleyes during the early spring:

It's a traditional thing on Pymatuning this early in the season: fishing for walleye in shallow water.Since the open season allows for taking walleyes during the spawning season, many anglers cash in on the action. The sport is available for both the wading and boat angler. The spawning bite may last for about a month.Key areas are gravel points and humps that provide the necessary spawning ingredients. Such spots top out at about three feet and see plenty of wind and wave action.Though a few stragglers can be caught during the day, the peak activity takes place during the last hour or two of daylight and often continues into the darkness.It's not hard to find the major areas, especially the ones with nearby land access, as wading anglers will be present. Boat anglers have more spots to choose from, including small humps that cannot be reached from shore.Day in and day out, the most productive presentation is a one-eighth ounce leadhead jig dressed with a three-inch chartreuse curly tail grub. Fish are also taken on jig-n-minnow combinations and small minnow baits like a Countdown or Husky Jerk Rapala.Whether you are fishing from a boat or wading, be sure not to crowd your fellow angler.

Warm, sunny days will quickly elevate the surface temperatures. If the wind is light, the warmer water will stack up along the windy shore.Walleyes can be taken by longline trolling a minnowbait like a small Rapala through the shallows. Keep the trolling speed low, just enough to keep the plug working.The most productive areas not only will be warmer, but they also might include structure and cover.A surface temperature readout on a sonar unit is a definite plus this time of year.

While much of the fishing activity takes place in the shallows during Pymatuning's early season, it's also possible to take fish in the deeper water. This is especially true of the larger females, fish that don't seem to spend much time in the shallows either before or after the spawn.The best way to reach these fish is to use leadcore line to pull the lure down to the fish zone.Leadcore line incorporates a thin filament of lead covered with a nylon sheath. The line acts as a sinker. The line is color coded, changing colors every 10 yards. It takes about three colors of line (90 feet) to pull a Rapala-style lure down to 18 to 20 feet.Once you find a productive zone, it's a simple matter to duplicate the set up. Experiment with different lure sizes and colors, as the fish can be particular. Lures that exhibit a more subtle action tend to be more productive in the cold water of early spring.Jeff Knapp is an outdoors columnist for the Butler Eagle.

Sid Brown of Greensburg holds the walleyes that he and Eagle columnist Jeff Knapp pulled from Pymatuning Lake early last spring.

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS