Site last updated: Thursday, November 19, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Twp. debates storing rifles

Guns are worth $22,000 each

BUTLER TWP — Commissioners are divided on the future of two .223-caliber rifles owned by the township police since 1961.

Sight-unseen, some collectors say the Colt Armalite AR-15 Model 01’s — which have the capacity to be fully automatic — are worth about $22,000 each.

“And that’s probably low,” said Commissioner Dave Zarnick, who at Monday night’s meeting advocated putting the guns back into storage, allowing the value — hopefully — to continue to quietly increase.

Fellow commissioner Joseph Hasychak agreed, and the two men offered up a resolution to mothball the weapons until further notice.

But commissioners Ben Simon and George Shockey voted against the storage idea, causing the it to fail on a 2-2 vote.

Commissioner Joseph Wiest, who holds the tie-breaking vote, was absent.

Simon, who said he’d like to see the topic come up again when a full set of board members is in attendance, said he favors selling the guns which were replaced for police use with newer model Smith & Wessons a handful of years back.

Shockey said he too doesn’t see a lot of reason to keep them.

“We aren’t a museum,” Shockey said.

The guns, which still are in excellent condition and work, initially were designed to be fully automatic, but by removing a piece from the trigger, they now are semiautomatic. The township still has the removed pieces that can be reinstalled. With fully automatic weapons off the market for private owners, that feature is increasing the weapon’s value.

Meantime, township manager Ed Kirkwood said a company has volunteered to give an official appraisal of the weapons for free. Kirkwood said he is unsure when the appraisal would occur, and township officials likely would not release the results because they do not want to skew the results of any future bids on the weapons.

Simon suggested the commissioners revisit the issue once they have the appraisal in hand.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS