Bridge to the past
Butler Area Library's genalogical expert
About 14 years ago, Meridian resident Ed Monnie attended a family reunion and realized the people who used to be the keepers of his family's history had died. The information they had carried in their heads was lost forever.
It started Monnie on a quest to fill in the blanks before any more family history could be lost.
"When I was a teenager, going to family reunions I sat with the people my age and avoided the 'old' people who were probably about 35 years old at the time," Monnie said with a laugh. "I never asked how we were related to all those people. I just accepted that we were."
Still, Monnie was surprised years later when "I asked someone, 'What was your grandfather's name?' and he wasn't sure."
In generations past, the family gathered around the chair of grandma or grandpa to listen to family stories.
Maybe there was a photo album with handwritten white-ink identifications under each picture. It was more than entertainment. Children learned that they were part of something larger.
Nowadays grandma has moved to Florida to be near her sister and grandpa went to Arizona with his second wife. Aunts and uncles have followed their jobs to the ends of the country or been posted overseas on military duty. The people who might have told the family stories are too busy and the kids are too easily distracted by video games and sports.
Who will keep the family history from getting lost?
Pat Collins of Butler began her own search for her family's oral history about 15 years ago. She learned something very valuable.
"Find the oldest relative available and tap into their memories," she advised.
But keep very good records.
"You'll find you're working more than one branch of the family at the same time so you have to be careful about timelines and keep the genealogy straight," she said.
Collins was fortunate to discover a 15-year-old who had inherited her great-grandmother's records of the family. Still, she double-checked the information - memories are often faulty. It paid to have documentation such as birth or death certificates to back up the verbal information.
Butler Area Public Library's genealogical expert, Luanne Eisler, agreed. Despite the fact that most people use a tape recorder or video camera for interviews, they should remember that the stories might not exactly match.
"The details of the same story will probably differ from one person to another because the memories are from that individual's point of view. This doesn't make them less valid, it's just a matter of different perspectives," Eisler explained.
Audio and videotapes have made the interview process easier and better. They not only record the exact words but they also record the tone of voice and inflection. In the case of videotapes, they record the facial expressions and the body language of the person being interviewed.
Unfortunately many people are self-conscious or camera-shy so the interviewer has to accept that not everyone will agree to a recording. Eisler emphasized that the wishes of the person being interviewed must be respected above all else. In those cases, paper and pen have to suffice.
Some people are less interested in formal research into their family tree than they are in anecdotal stories. For informal "story telling" sessions, Eisler suggested an activity such as baking cookies in the kitchen might be a good venue for the interview. The conversation could be recorded during the work and might even relate to it.
Open-ended requests such as, "Tell me what it was like making cookies when you were little," would be a better way to start the memory flow than questions that could be answered with "yes" or "no."
Another tactic is to start with non-threatening, factual information. The interviewer might ask, "What was your mother's maiden name? Where did she live?"
Questions of a more sensitive nature should be held until after a rapport has been established. This technique is particularly effective for people who haven't met before.
In either case, the key to a successful interview is advance preparation, according to Eisler.
First, a foundation of general information should be prepared. A few questions might be jotted down to start the conversation. The other person must be aware and agreeable to being recorded or video taped.
An informal contract stating what use will be made of the recording should be drawn up ahead of time for signature.
It's critical the people being interviewed be made to feel at ease – letting them chose the times and places for interviews can be a big help. Their need for privacy should always be respected. It might be too intrusive to record an especially traumatic life-experience.
Eisler, Monnie and Collins emphasized the need to document interviews. Names, date and location should be ''tagged" (stated clearly) at the beginning of each tape for later reference.
Monnie admitted he had made an attempt at tracing his family's history about twenty-five years ago.
"I suffered from lack of direction. I collected a lot of information from visiting relatives, family Bibles, cemeteries and such and then I just filed it in a 'stuff' file in my 'stuff' room. When I started to work on the history again I couldn't remember when or where I found the information or who told me what story," he said.
Collins began making calls only after she completed basic research through marriage, birth and death certificates; family records; census records; and real estate transactions. She was uncomfortable making initial calls but she pressed on.
"Don't be shy," she said. "Just call them or e-mail them. Contact anyone who's still living. Many will be interested. Some will have stuff stored away in a closet thinking no one else is interested in it," she said. "And don't expect to get it all in one session. Call back. Set up another interview if you must. Don't wear out the person or your welcome by trying to do it all at once."
Eisler explained there are many benefits.
"(Oral histories) can create a bond between the generations. It validates the lives of those who are older. It reinforces that their experiences are important.
"And younger people gain a role model. They learn what values their family holds dear and why. They learn the family traits and traditions. Sometimes they even become friends with older relatives.
"But you don't have to like the person to get to know them and learn their story," Eisler said.
Once the oral history interview has been completed, it should be transcribed because tapes can break or get ruined. Eisler estimated it may take up to six or eight hours to transcribe a one-hour tape.
When it's finished it's a good idea to make at least two copies. One to keep and one to present to the person who was interviewed.
Monnie advised using titles like "Memories of…" or "According to…" with the person's name.
Eisler went a step further and suggested desktop publishing software could be used to intersperse genealogy and reminiscences with family recipes and scanned-in photographs to create a unique graduation or wedding gift.
She said it all boils down to being remembered.
"I want to be remembered. If I want to be remembered I need to remember those who went before me," she said.
Collins had a simpler reason.
"It's so much fun to watch the memories come out," she said.
