Site last updated: Monday, November 16, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

State shuts down personal care home

The state Department of Welfare on Friday conducted an emergency relocation of 15 residents at this personal care home in Clearfield Township.
Official calls conditions poor

CLEARFIELD TWP — The state has shut down a personal care home on Harris Road.

The Department of Welfare on Friday ordered the business at 135 Harris Road closed and conducted an emergency relocation of 15 residents.

Ronald Melusky, director of the department’s Bureau of Human Services Licensing, said conditions were poor at the building.

“Emergency relocation of residents is extremely rare,” Melusky said.

He said of the more than 1,300 personal care homes across the state, the department of welfare shuts down an average of seven a year.

“That more than speaks for itself,” Melusky said.

He said the state determined the residents’ health was at risk if they remained.

Another problem was proprietor Kimberly Fair did not have a license to operate Kim’s Caring Cabin.

Although Fair could not be reached for comment, one of her boarders who does not require personal care, was at the building Tuesday afternoon.

Boarder Charles Mickey said Fair has opted to run a bed-and-breakfast rather than try to cut through government red tape to continue operating a facility.

“We just moved in about a week ago,” he said.

However, no one may be living in the house soon.

The state brought in a code enforcement officer, who declared the building unfit for habitation. A five-day notice to vacate was posted Monday.

The Butler County Area Agency on Aging received an anonymous tip about the home on Friday, leading to an unannounced visit at 4:45 p.m.

Beth Herold, AAA administrator, said the county visits licensed personal care homes four times a year.

However, the tip was crucial in uncovering this situation.

“We’d never hit this because it didn’t have a license,” Herold said.

She said conditions in the home were among the worst she’s seen.

“They were very poor,” Herold said. “It was very dirty, cluttered.”

She said there also were animals, including birds and a boa constrictor, in the house.

Herold saw animal feces on the floor.

“I was so shocked,” she said.

Herold said the residents seemed to be sluggish.

“Many of them were lethargic,” she said.

Once the county decided the home’s conditions were unacceptable, the state was notified.

Melusky said there was minimal food and the building was unsanitary.

Herold said all the residents requiring care were relocated by 3 a.m.

An 86-year-old woman was taken to Butler Memorial Hospital for evaluation.

“She was a little confused,” Herold said.

She said the personal care home had no charts or resident identification, so there was a delay in identifying who some of the people were.

Herold said another issue was medication appeared to be missing based on the dates of pill punch packs.

According to Herold, 100 pills should have remained.

The former residents were relocated to facilities in Butler and Allegheny counties. Herold said all 15 people are from Allegheny County.

This is the second time this year the state has shut down a personal care home involving Fair.

In February, the welfare department initiated an emergency relocation of residents living in the Carole Timpani Personal Care Home in Gibsonia, where Fair was an employee.

When Carole Timpani Bender, who operated that business, sent written notice to the state that the home would close, she indicated Fair would lease the building from Timpani Bender.

In March, the state determined the building still was serving as a personal care home despite not having a license to do so.

Although Fair appealed the state’s order to cease operation, that process does not permit an unlicensed personal care home to stay open in the interim.

The state in April issued Fair a second order to cease operation.

Melusky said she then moved the operation to the Harris Road building.

Herold said the original personal care home on Harris Road was Lakewood Manor, which was operated by Randy Wofford.

He voluntarily closed the business several months ago. Fair subsequently leased the building from him.

Melusky said the latest resident relocation was the result of a collaborative effort between the state and county.

Along with AAA, the county mental health/intellectual disabilities department provided assistance.

Herold lauded the East Butler Volunteer Fire Department for also providing aid.

She said people needing to place their loved ones in a personal care facility should verify the business is licensed with the state.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS