Site last updated: Saturday, November 21, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Fiscal feud fuels vote

Budget motion defeated again

BUTLER TWP — Butler School Board member Bill Halle has been feuding with the majority of board members since February, and Monday night he was at it again.

At the board meeting, Halle made a motion for the fourth time since Feb. 11 that would require the board to pass a balanced budget each year without reducing the district’s reserve fund below 5 percent of its expenses.

With eight board members in attendance, the measure was defeated in a 5 to 3 vote. Supporting Halle’s motion were Jim Keffalas and Karen Callihan.

Linda Patten was absent.

The state school code requires an annual balanced budget and the board has done so through a combination of cutting positions through attrition, property tax increases and the use of reserve funds.

The board has spent about $1.6 million of its reserve in the past four years, and has about $7.7 million remaining, said Cathy Rodgers, director of business services, more than the required amount.

“I think it’s ridiculous,” said resident Charles “Chas” Tanner of the balanced budget proposal, during the public comment period preceding the vote. “I think it’s a simplistic approach to working with budgeting in a public enterprise.”

Tanner is a Democratic candidate for the school board in the May 21 primary.

Board members agreed.

Board Vice President Helene Abramowitz said, “If you look at the amount, $1.6 million taken from the fund balance, you could have cut 28 teachers or raised taxes an additional 4 mills. That’s more burden on the taxpayer to balance the budget.”

Don Pringle, board president, was against the idea too.

“It’s a catch phrase. ‘Let’s balance the budget,’” he said.

John Conrad, board member, agreed: “I think it’s a simplistic approach. A political statement.”

Also opposing Halle’s motion were Paula Opalka and Carmen Bianco.

Nevertheless, Halle continues to push for education program cuts, even if the board already has voted against them.

On Monday he distributed a plan in response to Pringle’s previous request for Halle’s budget cuts.

Halle wrote, “My opinion is that they should be researched and reviewed according to their impact in dollars and cents on the budget and in an effort to address BASD’s ongoing budget deficits and recent tax increases.”

But the board has already voted down many of his ideas before.

For example, once again Halle suggested that the board cut the district’s Japanese language program and the ungraded junior high school enrichment classes, called ESP classes.

In addition, he called for larger class sizes for honors and advanced placement courses, which the board also previously rejected.

“We have to make changes in programming, staffing and different things to account for the budget,” Halle said.

“We look at the budget every year,” Pringle said, adding that Rodgers spends considerable time looking at the budget.

“We would charge the administration to make expansive and detrimental cuts,” he said.

But Halle was unconvinced: “We have to come to a point where we do what we can afford. Because of the budget process, we don’t talk about how we can.”

Halle wants the board to discuss collective bargaining unit givebacks, an idea the board previously rejected because it would require re-opening contract negotiations, which Halle disputes.

Although he wants to be involved with spending details, he said, he also has been dissatisfied with the administration’s efforts to answer his requests.

For example, an administration report that outlined the salaries and benefits for every school district employee has gone untouched since it was produced at his request.

And in March, Carolyn Cornish, assistant superintendent, provided a description of programs used at elementary schools to help children learn to read, again at his request.

On Monday Halle suggested the costs of “additional programming” should be examined for both reading and math students who are not proficient on state tests.

The school district regularly gives reports on the progress of its cyber school, and has begun to offer college courses during the school day.

However, Halle again expressed his dissatisfaction with the pace of the cyber school, calling for more blended education, and for college courses to be a source of district revenue.

Abramowitz said, “Looking at this (the cuts Halle distributed), I see a lot of harm coming to our successful students.”

But Halle disagreed.

“With all due respect you’ve made general comments without data,” he said, referring to financial data.

“These are the least expensive kids in the system,” said Pringle. “I can make a pretty good guess that they’re going to be successful all through life.”

But Halle was unimpressed, saying his primary goal is to cut the school’s budget before the district is “broke.”

Administrators have shaved $1 million off the 2012-13 budget and the board will examine consolidating the district’s elementary schools and outsourcing its technology functions. The board also decided Monday to pursue bond refinancing that will save the district $51,000.

School budgets change throughout the year as funding is solidified and personnel changes take place. The district’s final 2013-14 budget will depend upon staff retirements that are due in May and state and federal funding amounts that may not be available when the district reaches its state-mandated budget deadline on June 30.

Halle dominated a recent budget work session with requests for education program cuts, while administrators, teachers and a majority of other board members focused on maintaining the existing education program.

With three board members’ terms up in December, Halle believes the tone of the board could change, he said.

Conrad, the only board member running for re-election, said, “You talk about who has skin in the game. He’s not a graduate of Butler and his kids didn’t graduate from Butler.”

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS