Eckstein cleared of discrimination
An investigation into allegations of sexual discrimination by Butler County Commissioner Jim Eckstein found there was insufficient evidence that anything occurred.
However, the report does claim Eckstein's conduct leaves the county vulnerable to possible legal action.
According to a 12-page report issued May 9 by the Pittsburgh firm of Thomas, Thomas & Hafer, “Our investigation showed that Mr. Eckstein arguably mistreats his peers and subordinates, both male and female. If his behavior continues, he will no doubt continue to expose himself and the county to claims and potential liability.”
Eckstein vehemently denies he is guilty of mistreating anyone. He said the report was biased.
“I don't think the report was objective,” Eckstein said.
Commissioner Bill McCarrier, board chairman, disagreed. He said the firm is correct in stating Eckstein's behavior places the county in a precarious position.
Commissioner Dale Pinkerton also agreed with the findings.
Several sources previously identified chief clerk Amy Wilson as the person who filed the complaint.
Wilson on Tuesday declined to confirm or deny she was the employee.
“Because this involves an internal investigation, I'm going to decline to comment on it,” she said.
Eckstein also declined to identify who filed the complaint.
“I'm not allowed to do that,” he said.
Since the employee filed the complaint through the county and not an outside agency or the court, it is a personnel issue.
The copy of the 12-page report provided to the Butler Eagle redacted references to the employee's identity.
The firm reported there is no evidence of sexual discrimination because the terms, conditions or privileges of the person's employment with the county was not “materially” altered.
Eckstein agreed with that finding.
“There is no evidence of sexual discrimination,” he said.
The report also states there is ample evidence Eckstein was motivated by factors other than discrimination.
According to the report, “Eckstein's treatment of (the employee), albeit undesirable and, at times, out of place in an office setting, appears to be motivated by Mr. Eckstein's documented concern about issues relating to potential government waste and misuse of county resources and revenues.”
The county in January hired the firm to investigate the internal complaint.
County solicitor Mike English deferred conducting the investigation himself, citing a conflict of interest since he represents all three commissioners.
The contract was for an amount not to exceed $5,000.
Eckstein, who unsuccessfully argued for English to do the investigation, said the county should not have hired the firm.
“The $5,000 was a waste of money,” Eckstein said. “It (the complaint) should have been turned in to the EEOC (U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission).
McCarrier justified the expense: “It has to be investigated. The only thing you can do to prevent that is to modify your behavior.”
According to Eckstein, the complaint stemmed from a discussion he had with that employee following a county prison board meeting in December.
He said the person who filed the complaint lectured him about what he shouldn't say during public meetings. Eckstein maintains the employee was out of line trying to stop him from bringing to light issues facing the county.
“To me, that is unconscionable,” he said.
The firm interviewed nine witnesses, whose names were provided by the employee filing the internal complaint, about Eckstein's behavior after the prison board meeting and at other times.
Eckstein said at least some of the people interviewed were apparently present for the discussion following the December prison board meeting.
“I would assume that,” he said.
Eckstein said he should not have been questioned after the nine witnesses and should have been given the opportunity to offer his own witnesses.
“To hear both sides of the story,” he said.
Eckstein pointed out the firm billed the county for nearly $4,700 worth of work before interviewing him.
“They've been working on this for two months and haven't contacted me,” he said.
McCarrier defended the process by the firm, saying he believed all the witnesses were county officials or employees.
Although the witnesses differed on whether Eckstein's behavior toward the person filing the complaint and women in county government constituted sexual discrimination, most agreed he treats people badly.
One witness did not criticize Eckstein, describing the commissioner as speaking in an “excited” manner the day of the December meeting.
After filing the initial complaint against Eckstein, the employee alleged he retaliated by trying to restrict that worker's authority.
The report pointed out Eckstein's stance on limiting what the employee could do without the commissioners' prior approval is consistent with his previous actions.
According to the report, “Mr. Eckstein's efforts to limit (the employee) ... is entirely in keeping with his very public history of the micromanagement of fiscal matters and with his stated commitment to transparency in government.”
This was the second allegation of sexual discrimination filed against Eckstein since he took office in 2012.
Joyce Ainsworth, director of County Children and Youth Services, last year filed a complaint with the EEOC.
Ainsworth, who did not seek a financial settlement, alleged Eckstein mistreated her during the Feb. 29, 2012, commissioners meeting.
The commissioners last December settled that case, agreeing to attend a training session covering such topics as bullying in the workplace and issuing a statement of support for Ainsworth.
Eckstein maintains he's innocent of those charges as well. He said the only county personnel who have issues with him are in management.
“The rank and file has not complained about me,” Eckstein said. “They come up and thank me for trying to make a fair work environment.”
