Site last updated: Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

No hurry to decide new QB

OK, Steeler fans and media types, all together now, let’s take a deep breath.

Please!!

The Steelers have been in training camp at Saint Vincent College for all of a few days and people are already pulling their hair out over daily developments on the team’s quarterback front.

Mason Rudolph is getting some first-team reps. Kenny Pickett is listed third on the depth chart. Mitch Trubisky is expected to be the eventual starter, though the Steelers are painting this as a three-way competition going into camp.

Pittsburgh sports talk shows — callers and hosts — are in a lather over these proceedings.

Yet these proceedings are only just beginning.

Can everyone just relax and see how it plays out?

If Pickett stays No. 3 on the depth chart all season, it would mean two things: Trubisky is playing pretty well and Rudolph has progressed enough to be in the mix. And Pickett would spend a year getting acclimated to the NFL.

In terms of the Steelers’ success on the field, that scenario doesn’t seem so bad.

Quarterback Jordan Love was a first-round draft choice by Green Bay a few years ago and he’s still sitting behind Aaron Rodgers. The Packers haven’t exactly been suffering from this. They lose in the playoffs, but they’re getting there every year.

And remember, Rodgers sat for a few years while Brett Favre played out his successful run behind center for the Packers. That wait to begin his active NFL playing career didn’t exactly harm Rodgers.

Maybe Pickett winds up winning the starting job. Ideally, Trubisky does well in camp and in preseason games, but Pickett out-shines him and wins the job outright. That would be exciting.

The biggest shock of all, of course, would be Rudolph winning the job. If that were to happen, Trubisky would likely be No. 2 and Pickett No. 3. No one, including myself, believes that this will happen.

But you never know.

Bottom line is, the Steelers and their fans haven’t had to go into a season wondering who the starting quarterback would be for nearly 20 years. A quarterback competition does add some spice to the preseason, does it not?

Steeler fans will be paying much closer to preseason games this time around.

In fact, many will be screaming if Rudolph gets on the field before Pickett, or if Pickett gets on the field before Trubisky, if one quarterback gets stuck with the third-teamers while another is with the first team ... or whatever.

A word of advice here. Just calm down.

Whoever plays with whom in what quarter of what preseason games — it’s OK. This is professional football. The coaches will start whatever quarterback gives them the best chance to win.

In pro ball, winning is the goal. Period.

John Enrietto is sports editor of the Butler Eagle

More in

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS