Site last updated: Monday, November 16, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Eckstein attacks Doerr, Pinkerton

Jim Eckstein
He claims they are conspiring against him

Butler County Commissioner Jim Eckstein on Wednesday accused fellow Commissioner Dale Pinkerton of cutting two elected county posts to gain leverage in a defamation lawsuit.

Eckstein claimed Pinkerton's real motivation for pushing for the elimination of the two part-time jury commissioners was to enable county President Judge Thomas Doerr to taint the jury pool for lawsuits filed against Eckstein.

“I don't have a crystal ball, but I have a theory of just how far this county government has regressed into an unethical abyss,” Eckstein said.

In addition to a defamation lawsuit filed by Pinkerton, county personnel director Lori Altman and her husband, state Trooper Scott Altman lodged a second civil complaint against Eckstein.

The Altmans and Pinkerton maintain Eckstein slandered them. Eckstein insists he's innocent.

The commissioners cut the two part-time posts at the May 23 meeting while Eckstein was attending a conference elsewhere. Pinkerton made the motion, which was seconded by Commissioner Bill McCarrier.

Pinkerton denied Eckstein's theory had any merit, saying he only pushed for the change to save the county money.

“I did it for financial reasons,” Pinkerton said.

The county court administration previously stated the office could absorb the duties of the part-time jobs without hiring additional staff.

The county jury commission is comprised of the part-time jury commissioners and Doerr until the end of the year.

Pinkerton pointed out Doerr can't taint a jury because the attorneys for both sides of a lawsuit select jurors from a pool of prospective candidates through interviews.

“It is not selected by the judges,” Pinkerton said.

Doerr, who was in court during the commissioners meeting, also refuted Eckstein's accusations.

“It is not possible for anyone in any way to alter the process,” Doerr said about jury selection.

He explained the jury pool is derived using a computer system drawing names from voter registrations.

The state law empowering county commissioners to cut jury commissioner posts is being challenged in state court.

Individuals or groups also could sue the county over eliminating the jury commissioners.

Doerr said if the jury commissioner posts are not restored there would be witnesses to him issuing lists of prospective jurors.

“It would be a public event,” he said.

Doerr stressed jury tampering has never occurred in the county.

“Jury tampering is a very serious criminal offense,” he said.

Eckstein compared the possibility of jury tampering with the infamous 1980 rigging of the Pennsylvania Lottery.

He said people used to claim the lottery couldn't be fixed either.

Eckstein previously questioned how the court administration could assume the jury commissioner duties without adding staff.

Doerr said the court schedule alternates between peak and slow periods, which can be planned around.

According to Eckstein, the defamation lawsuits are part of an ongoing scheme to discredit and bankrupt him.

“I'm up to $35,000,” he said about his legal defense costs.

Eckstein also accused Doerr of conspiring with Commissioner Bill McCarrier to label Eckstein a potential danger to others.

Doerr in November issued a court order directing a sheriff's deputy be stationed in the commissioners office.

A few weeks later, Doerr amended the order enabling deputies to regularly patrol the office on the fifth floor of the government center.

Doerr said on Dec. 7 the extra security was warranted considering Eckstein's conduct. Doerr described Eckstein as agitated and aggressive, which may cause others to fear the prospect of a physical confrontation.

Eckstein maintains Doerr's order was politically motivated.

“Bill McCarrier reaches out to President Judge Thomas Doerr about a security issue in the executive branch of our county,” Eckstein said. “What is the issue? The issue is Jim Eckstein — he's not behaving and not doing what we're telling him to do.”

McCarrier denied there is any plot against Eckstein.

“As usual, Commissioner Eckstein's remarks were ridiculous,” McCarrier said.

Doerr agreed there was no conspiracy, saying there was no joint decision between McCarrier and him to order extra security for the commissioners office.

“I was simply responding to complaints,” he said.

Eckstein said later on Wednesday his claims were not the result of paranoia.

“This is logic and common sense,” he said. “It's pretty easy to say Jim Eckstein is a liar.”

Doerr disagreed.

“I've been in office 27 years, and I don't really care what Jim Eckstein says about me,” Doerr said. “The problem with his comments is they're illegitimately undermining the credibility of the court system of Butler County, and the people of Butler County deserve better.”

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS