Including the 2005 class, the Butler Area Sports Hall of Fame has 290 total members and 165 living members.

The Hall of Fame membership includes 14 women, one priest (Father William Savage, 1977) and one minister (Rev. Clair O. Dufford, 1983).

One grandfather-granddaughter combination - Butler "Doggie" Cavalero and Lisa Zitalone - exists in the Hall of Fame.

Five father-son combos - Frank and John Stuper, Tony and Dale Betty, Charles and Frank LeFever, Jim McElhaney Sr. and Jim McElhaney Jr., Don and Sam Cavalero - exist in the Hall of Fame.

Six brother combos - Rocco and Merle Ianotti, Bill, Rich and Ron Saul, Bob and Bill Beneigh, Joe and John Gracik, Larry and Bob Paffrath, Bill and Terry Rettig - exist in the Hall of Fame.

One husband-wife combo - Mark Smith and Jodie Imbrie Smith - exists in the Hall of Fame.

The Hall of Fame features six NFL players: Bill, Rich and Ron Saul, Terry Hanratty, Scott Milanovich and Tom Brown.

The Hall of Fame features four major league baseball players - Ron Kline, Milt Graff, John Stuper, Rube Waddell - and two umpires, Ed Vargo and Bill Hohn.

The Hall of Fame features three Olympians - Eric Namesnik, David Pichler, Calvin Schake - and Olympic coaches Marty Cypher (weight lifting) and Bill Reith (fencing).