Defense contracts good for economy
A Department of Defense contract may conjure up images of working at the Pentagon or in the Middle East.
However, the military also needs mundane items and services, and many companies in Butler County fill these needs. And that brings lots of money here.
Between 2000 and 2011, there were 2,971 defense contracts bringing in $574.6 million to 121 contractors in the county.
This ranges from Ibis Tek of Middlesex Township, which was the leading contractor in the county with 1,130 contracts totaling $195.7 million, down to the Insight Pipe of Lancaster Township, which had two contracts totaling $787.
The most lucrative year in the county was 2010, when 379 contracts brought in $115.1 million. The least lucrative year was 2003, when 59 contracts brought in $8.5 million.
The year with the most contracts was 2009, with 536, and the year with the fewest contracts was 2000, with only 21.
“We're always looking for small businesses that have a product, service, innovation ... that can help support the mission of our sailors and marines,” said Sean Crean, director of the office of small business programs for the Department of the Navy.
Renee Decker, a contract specialist at the Government Contracting Assistance Center at Slippery Rock University, said that defense and other government contracts bring more money to companies, which leads to people spending more money at other businesses.
“It definitely strengthens the community,” Decker said. “This is why we exist at the university.”
Dennis Thompson, senior vice president at SCRA Applied Research and Development in Wexford, said companies with lots of defense contracts, just like companies adding employees or new companies moving in, can have a positive impact on the local economy.
He said this can lead to a ripple effect to surrounding contractors, creating upswings in housing, manufacturing and other companies.
“There's no question,” Thompson said about the economic impact of military spending.
Between 2000 and 2011, Pennsylvania had 216,261 military contracts bringing in $103 billion to 9,003 contractors.
Bucks County had the most contracts, 43,887. Allegheny County had the most contractors, 1,060. Delaware County had the most money, $25.9 billion.
Cameron County had no contracts awarded between 2000 and 2011.
Compared to surrounding counties, Butler County had more contracts and brought in more money except for Allegheny and Westmoreland counties.
Although many contractors work on projects such as ballistic vehicles, Decker said the military also relies on contractors to supply items such as food services and office supplies.
“Pretty much anything that you or I need in a day, the government also is buying,” Decker said.
Although some projects are done in-house by the military, Thompson said most things are done by outside contractors.
“That's been the practice for years,” Thompson said.
Crean said that work such as system engineering, design and finances are done in-house.
Ibis Tek had contracts to work on combat and noncombat vehicles, among other items. The Seneca Valley School District had contracts in 2011, 2006, 2004 and 2003 to provide food services related to its Army Junior ROTC summer camp.
The positive impact of these contracts may be tempered by the sequestration that started March 1.
Sequestration means $1.2 trillion in federal spending cuts during 10 years, half of which will come from defense spending.
“Basically, they're going to shut everything down,” Thompson said.
The cuts came about because of the Budget Control Act of 2011, which reduces the federal government's deficit and spending.
Crean said the chief of naval operations has projected a $4.6 billion shortfall for the 2013 fiscal year for the Navy because of sequestration. He said that there likely will be a big impact on contractors.
He said that there are a number of directives being put in place to help close that budget gap. He said maintenance on ships during the third and fourth quarter is being delayed.
Ryan Grauer, an international relations professor at the University of Pittsburgh, said that no one is sure what will be affected by the cuts. He said companies with larger contracts likely will be more affected than companies with smaller contracts.
Grauer said the cuts will be more detrimental to future contracts rather than ones already in place. But he said the immediate impact of sequestration will not be as bad as some are expecting.
“It's hard to quickly turn off the tap,” Grauer said.
Some sources talking about cuts are discussing actions such as laying off civilian employees and delaying maintenance, and they are not talking about contractors, he said.
“It's generally not focused on contractors,” Grauer said.
Thompson believes that sequestration only will last a month or two, at which time Congress will work out a better solution. However, even if it lasts a while, it could take more than six months to completely recover from the expected economic slowdown that will follow.
He said that Maryland-based defense contractor Lockheed Martin already has decided to lay off 20,000 employees.
“Even a month or two will be devastating for the economy,” Thompson said.
He said any company that has government contracts will be affected. He said it will depend on whether individual companies have enough other work to be able to handle losing government contracts.
“That's going to be an individual decision,” Thompson said.
In the Pittsburgh region, he said, it is likely that the growing industry surrounding the Marcellus and Utica shale natural gas will provide some insulation from recession.
Scott Deutsch, a spokesman for the National Center for Defense Manufacturing and Machining in Blairsville, said that many of the group's clients have expressed concern about sequestration.
“People are worried,” Deutsch said.
The nonprofit group brings expertise to different companies with defense contracts and tries to make those companies work more efficiently on contracted projects.
Deutsch said the group has saved the Department of Defense more than $1 billion in the past 10 years just through cost savings and cost avoidance.
Because of the nature of the group's work, he said that it is not that concerned about sequestration.
“We look at it as a challenge,” Deutsch said.
Crean said that the government can terminate contracts if necessary. However, if a contract is terminated, companies have the right to file a claim.
“Each contract will be looked at individually,” Crean said.
He said that the Navy will work to avoid canceling contracts as much as possible.
“We will try everything we can to mitigate the impact on the contracts that we have in place,” Crean said.
Here is how Butler County compares to surrounding counties when it comes to getting military contracts between 2000 and 2011:• Butler County had 2,971 contracts worth $574.6 million to 121 contractors• Allegheny County had 13,808 contracts worth $16.8 billion to 1,060 contractors• Armstrong County had 326 contracts worth $128.1 million to 28 contractors• Beaver County had 305 contracts worth $18 million to 65 contractors• Clarion County had nine contracts worth $566,905 to seven contractors• Lawrence County had 122 contracts worth $12.8 million to 29 contractors• Mercer County had 362 contracts worth $87.5 million to 50 contractors• Venango County had 136 contracts worth $16.4 million to 20 contractors• Westmoreland County had 3,676 contracts worth $826.9 million to 216 contractors<B><I>Source: www.governmentcontractswon.com, a public information website</I></B>
