Trump still owed $5M
NEW YORK — A Cranberry Township woman still has to pay real estate mogul Donald Trump $5 million after claiming that the Miss USA 2012 pageant was rigged.
U.S. District Judge J. Paul Oetken for the Southern District of New York on Tuesday upheld a December decision ordering Sheena Monnin, the former Miss Pennsylvania 2012, to pay Trump and the Miss Universe Organization.
Monnin resigned her post in protest shortly after the national pageant in June 2012.
She claimed to have heard of a list that had the winners of the pageant before those winners were announced.
She proceeded to take her claims of the rigged pageant to national television talk shows and quickly became a target of the lawsuit filed by Trump, who runs the Miss Universe Organization.
Monnin petitioned the court to vacate the December award, saying that arbitrator Theodore Katz exceeded the scope of his powers, that Monnin was not notified of the arbitration hearing and what it was to resolve, and that Katz’s decision disregarded the law.
Oetken said that Katz acted within his powers and did not disregard the law.
He also said that Monnin’s lawyer, Richard Klineburger of Haddonfield, N.J., poorly represented her. After Monnin and her lawyer did not appear for mediation hearings, the case went to arbitration. Monnin and Klineburger were not present for the arbitration, either.
The arbitrator said Monnin’s allegations cost the pageant a $5 million fee from a potential 2013 sponsor.
Although there was communication between the arbitrator and Klineburger, Monnin was under the impression that the case was being handled by Klineburger and he told her that she did not have to participate in arbitration.
Despite this, Oetken found the arbitration process to be fair and the notification to be fair.
“Sympathy, or apparent inequity, may play no role in a court’s legal analysis, and here, the law is clear,” Oetken wrote.
Despite the court’s ruling against her, Monnin maintains that the Miss Universe organization “manipulated” the contest judges.
In a statement released on Facebook, Monnin said she hoped for a different outcome, but said she feels that the “true nature of the Miss USA judging procedure has been exposed.”
“This is not about me being a ‘sore loser’ or wanting my ‘15 minutes of fame.’ This is about the MUO’s admission under oath that they manipulate the judges’ results to suit their own ends. This is not what they advertise to the public,” Monnin said.
Trump’s lawyer, Michael Cohen, said he applauded the judge’s decision but was surprised Monnin stood by her story.
“I’m shocked to see that she has yet to learn her lesson. I thought she would be smarter the second time around,” Cohen said.
Monnin said she is accepting donations for her legal defense fund.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
