Site last updated: Thursday, November 19, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Suspects face trial in death

James Sullivan
Witness describes man's fatal beating

KITTANNING — Nearly 100 family and friends — at points emotional, tense or openly sobbing — witnessed the first court appearance for four men charged in the St. Patrick’s weekend beating death of a Butler County man.

A single eyewitness testified that James Sullivan, a 39-year-old military veteran from Donegal Township, was pummeled to death as he lay defenseless in the street outside Kittanning’s Wick City Saloon.

Following the hearing, District Judge James Owen decided all four defendants will now go to the Armstrong County Court of Common Pleas where they may have a trial or enter a plea on a homicide charge. They are: Anthony M. Bove, 18, and his stepfather, Otilio Cosme, 43, both of Ford City; 32-year-old Keith A. Brison of Kittanning; and Dennis A. Rosenberger, 27, of Kittanning.

Initially, Rosenberger was charged only with felony assault. But Armstrong County District Attorney Scott Andreassi said homicide was added to Rosenberger’s charges Wednesday after prosecutors reviewed autopsy information provided by Dr. Cyril Wecht.

Investigators believe Rosenberger sucker punched Sullivan, causing him to fall to the ground, where allegedly he was beaten to the point where ribs were broken and a major vein in his stomach was severed, causing massive internal bleeding.

But the updated autopsy results, Andreassi said, indicate blunt force trauma to Sullivan’s skull, likely caused when his head hit the pavement following Rosenberger’s punch, contributed to the death.

The autopsy results were entered into the record as part of an agreement by all the attorneys involved.

The only items noted from the report was Sullivan’s cause of death, which was trauma to the head and abdomen; his manner of death, which was homicide; and the victim’s blood alcohol level at the time of his death, which was 0.132 percent — more than 1½ times the 0.08 percent legal limit for driving.

Witness Zane Hassa, a security guard at ACMH Hospital, testified that he drove into the parking lot just as the fatal fray was beginning about 1:35 a.m.

According to Hassa’s testimony, after Rosenberger knocked Sullivan to the ground, Cosme stood on the downed man, stomping one foot at a time into Sullivan’s chest. Bove kicked the victim’s right side and Brison kicked the left.

The assault stopped, Hassa said, when another unidentified man apparently intervened and the group turned its attention to him.

The only other witness on Wednesday, state police Trooper Chris Birkbicher, testified that Rosenberger acknowledged during a taped interview that he sucker punched Sullivan.

Attorneys for the four defendants afterward questioned the credibility and consistency of Hassa’s testimony. But the judge said a preliminary hearing is not the proper venue to weigh credibility issues and during such a hearing evidence is viewed in the light most favorable to prosecutors.

Each attorney, arguing on behalf of his client, argued that the circumstances did not rise to the level of a homicide. They suggested the allegations instead were sufficient to support a charge of simple assault or reckless endangerment.

“This is at best a voluntary manslaughter case,” argued Phillip DiLucente of Pittsburgh, who represents Cosme.

The defendants, all wearing bright orange jail fatigues, showed no visible emotion during the brief proceedings. However, the crowd of spectators, who represented the victim as well as defendants, expressed a number of emotions during and after the hearing, ranging from disbelief and disappointment to all-out sobbing.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS