2 lacrosse players seek rulings
MECHANICSBURG — The Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association denied playing time to two Butler County lacrosse players, but one of those rulings was voided Wednesday morning by county President Judge Thomas Doerr.
After a hearing Friday, the PIAA said it would not allow a cooperative sponsorship agreement between Butler High School and St. Joseph High School in lacrosse.
Stuart and Dawn Surkosky of Butler had requested the Butler School District’s support for the sponsorship so that their son Jacob could play with Butler’s team. His school has no team.
Although the family had a majority of school board and some community support, the PIAA denied the request because the public school district where St. Joseph is located, Highlands, shares no border with the Butler district.
St. Joseph is a private school.
Instead, the PIAA suggested the Surkoskys go to the South Butler School District, which fields a lacrosse team and is contiguous to Highlands. Knoch’s team is a club team which represents the school but is not funded by it.
“I think justice has been served,” said Don Pringle, Butler School Board president who opposed the sponsorship because all St. Joseph students would have been permitted to play at Butler. “I was for the 7,500 students who attend the Butler School District.”
In the second lacrosse case, which was heard by Doerr, he granted an injunction against a PIAA ruling that would have denied eligibility for Hunter Ligo, a goalie for Sewickley Academy in Sewickley, who lives in Butler.
Ligo was scheduled to play a nonsection game Wednesday afternoon against Georgetown Preparatory School in Bethesda, Md., which is why the injunction was sought. A regular hearing now is set for 9 a.m. April 5.
Ligo, who attended Butler through ninth grade and played junior varsity lacrosse in 2008-09, had to repeat the ninth grade when he transferred. A hearing impairment and a negative social environment affected his school work in Butler, said his attorney Michael Pawk of Butler.
Pawk argued that no damage would result from the injunction, and that Sewickley would be willing to forfeit Wednesday’s game, or games, after a ruling on April 5, since postseason play is not affected.
He said Ligo was harmed by the PIAA decision because Ligo has been accepted by the College of Wooster in Wooster, Ohio, and that his coach doesn’t know he’s been ruled ineligible to play his senior year.
“It could affect his ability to play in college,” Pawk said.
This was Ligo’s fourth appeal of Western Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic League and PIAA rulings.
“Simply put it’s been a moving target,” said Pawk, regarding the eligibility rules.
Ligo played in five of 13 junior varsity games in 2008-09 but dressed for 14 varsity games he never played. Pawk wants the court to count 27 games, which would void his 2008-09 season.
The PIAA counted only junior varsity games, and said Ligo played in 38 percent of games, which is more than the 25 percent of games that make a season of play count toward the eight semesters players are eligible.
Pawk told the judge that each WPIAL and PIAA ruling reinterpreted the eligibility rules.
Pawk called the rulings “arbitrary” and “discriminatory.”
Jordan Webster of Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney represented the PIAA at the hearing, but said he had just received the motion 16 hours before.
“There is a sound reason for an eight semester rule,” Webster argued. “Other students requested a waiver because they were ill. Hunter did participate.”
