Site last updated: Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Karen Diehl touts CPA experience in seeking post

Karen Diehl, a certified public accountant from Franklin Township, is seeking the Republican nomination for Butler County Controller.

Karen Diehl wants to use her experience to benefit Butler County.

Diehl, 57, a certified public accountant from Franklin Township, is vying with Ben Holland for the Republican nomination for county controller.

She said her 23 years experience make her the most qualified candidate for county controller.

“I care about Butler County,” she said. “I know I could do a good job.”

Along with owning Diehl Accounting and Financial Services, she is a Franklin Township auditor.

Diehl is familiar with county finances. Before joining the firm she later bought, Diehl worked for a company that audited Armstrong County finances.

She views the role of the controller as the person who oversees county finances, being the watchdog for taxpayers’ money.

“I consider myself a fiscal conservative,” Diehl said.

She won’t make a decision on whether to sell her firm until the May 21 primary is over.

Diehl said if she wins and decides to keep the firm, someone would be delegated to run the business.

“I do know the controller’s job is full-time,” she said.

If elected, she plans to review the office to determine whether any changes should be made.

Diehl praised Controller Jack McMillin, who is retiring at the end of the year, for his work.

“I think Jack has done a good job,” she said.

Diehl plans to retain the office staff.

“I would hope so,” she said. “It is premature until I get down there and work with them.”

Earlier this year, the controller’s office was criticized for alleged overspending, including overtime costs.

McMillin eventually eliminated all overtime by ceasing to do discretionary work, which is not required under state law, for other offices and departments.

Diehl would review whether overtime in the controller’s office and doing discretionary work would be needed.

“You have to see what the workload is,” she said.

Diehl pointed out money was saved by McMillin’s office doing extra work even though overtime, which was approved by the county commissioners, was accrued as a result.

She said there was insufficient information presented when McMillin was denounced.

“We weren’t given all the numbers,” Diehl said.

There have been problems between the controller and other elected officials.

Diehl said there doesn’t have to be conflict between offices every time there is a disagreement.

The controller is on the county salary and prison boards with the commissioners.

Diehl said her friendship with county Commissioner Dale Pinkerton, whose wife Millie works for Deihl on part-time seasonal basis, wouldn’t affect her decisions.

“People who have sat on boards with me know I don’t hesitate to say what I believe is correct,” Diehl said.

She lives with her husband, Craig Diehl; her daughter, Lindsay; and her mother, Ila English.

Diehl is a member and past president of the Rotary Club of Butler as well as a board member for the Community Development Corporation of Butler County, the Butler County Industrial Development Association and the Butler County Children’s Center.

She has volunteered for the Community Health Clinic of Butler and worked on projects supporting Stand Tall, Lifesteps and the Paul Laurence Dunbar Community Center.

A 1974 graduate of Butler High School, Diehl earned a degree in business administration from Slippery Rock University.

The primary is May 21. There are no Democratic candidates for county controller.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS