Site last updated: Thursday, November 19, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Other Voices

After four years of contentious debate, the energy bill was seemingly resolved this week with polite compromise.

The House gave up proposals to roll back Clean Air rules and to grant legal immunity to manufacturers of a gasoline additive that pollutes groundwater.

The Senate, in turn, abandoned a requirement that utilities use more renewable fuels to produce electricity and a directive to cut oil use by a million barrels a day within 10 years.

And the showdown over drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge was put off until another day.

Congress is expected to pass the first comprehensive energy plan in 14 years by week's end, and the president plans to sign it by Aug. 1.

So, compromise thrives inside the Beltway and America's energy future is secure, right? Ha!

This bill is a lobbyists' paradise and a citizens' nightmare. It will do little to solve America's energy problems.

The United States needed innovation to wean it from foreign oil and adopt new fuels for the future - but little of that will occur from this "let's pass it and claim we did something" package.

Here's a sample idea from the bill: "Tougher requirements for federal alternative fuel fleets to ensure these vehicles actually use clean alternative fuels." The Saudi oil sheiks must be quivering in the face of such Yankee resolve.

How about this one? "Instructions to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration to look for ways to improve Corporate Automobile Fuel Efficiency standards." That's a weasel-worded admission that neither the House nor Senate has the guts to take the simple, vital step of requiring auto makers to make more-efficient cars.

China now has more ambitious gas-mileage standards than the United States.

While no energy bill could have alleviated today's high gas prices immediately, a balanced, forward-thinking bill could have set America on course to reduce gasoline consumption and diversify fuel supply. That's a must for our pocketbooks and our national security.

Instead, this bill overdoses on tax breaks to big energy companies at a time they're earning record profits.

The bill does plenty of other mischief, too. It gives the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission authority to approve siting of liquefied natural gas terminals over local objections. States and municipalities have raised questions about safeguarding such plants in an age of terrorism, especially in urban areas. Two LNG terminals have been proposed near Philadelphia.

The bill repeals the Public Utility Holding Company Act, which limits utility mergers. Hello, higher rates.

It also exempts various drilling and exploration projects from pesky rules such as the Clean Water Act and Safe Drinking Water Act.

It's one thing when compromise leads to solid law that balances competing public interests. It's another when it comes down to placating industry lobbyists. In this case, all that negotiation just wasn't worth the energy.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS