Perryman | How the Butler Eagle’s new Community Impact Fund can make a difference in Butler County
Think back to grade school. Did you ever have a teacher lead a game of telephone? They whispered something to a student, who then whispered it to the next student, who then whispered it to the next. How did the accuracy of the teacher’s statement hold up as it was passed by word-of-mouth student to student?
Communities that lose their local newspaper have a lot in common with that game. Information about local issues are passed by word-of-mouth or through social media. Facts get distorted, false information gets added and important things get omitted.
Your friends aren’t intentionally misleading you. But information that is true to their knowledge came from a friend they trust, who got it from a friend they trust, likely going back to someone who did know the facts and wouldn’t recognize the version that eventually gets to you.
You’re left with a community in which each individual has different, often contradicting, “facts.” There is no common ground to address problems from, or even agreement on what the problems even are.
There’s no accountability. There’s no holding truth to power. When any version of truth is as valid as any other, a lie denying wrongdoing is as valid as proof something wrong was done.
How much do you trust these facts recycled many times over? In a community without a local newspaper doing the work of verifying information from the source, it’s all you have left.
We don’t want to see that happen in Butler County. Rather, we want to do more than just maintain the status quo. We want to find more and better ways to partner with and serve our communities.
During a 12-hour long livestream on Thursday — viewable on Facebook and YouTube — we provided a look at some of the things we do, the place we see local journalism holding in the community and a glimpse of some of the things we hope to do in the future.
But we can’t do any of it alone. We need the community to partner with us.
On Thursday evening, the livestream ended with a small celebration at Vintage Coffeehouse, recognizing the Butler Eagle’s latest effort to ensure the future of quality local journalism, our Community Impact Fund.
Most of my adult life has been dedicated to local news. It hasn’t always been easy. It hasn’t always made me particularly good money. But overall, the chance to make a difference, big or small, has been worth it.
In those years, I have seen how more than a half-dozen newsrooms representing more than a dozen publications work.
The only constant I can definitively point to across all of those experiences is that each and every place I’ve worked as a journalist has been different. From their operations to their views on a newspaper’s place in the community to how they evaluate potential stories and allocate resources to them — no two places have had matching approaches.
A real comparison of all of that would be far too long and I’m not an interesting enough writer for it to hold your attention. So I want to focus on some of the things we at the Butler Eagle are working to do right and what it can look like in communities where newspapers have gone wrong.
I’m not here to claim the Butler Eagle is perfect. No news organization is.
That said, we actively evaluate how we do things, what we can provide readers and our role in the community. We aim to hold each other accountable, and we try to find ways to improve on those things, even when it isn’t the most lucrative choice.
One big things the Butler Eagle has going for it is being an independent publication. I have worked for independent newspapers, those owned by regional groups and those owned by companies with national reach. I can say an individual publication and its community benefit far more from smaller options than from any security provided by national outlets.
Independents have a freer hand to do the things that matter to their communities and the flexibility to change course when needed.
They can focus on what matters to the communities they serve. They can try new things and give unconventional stories or presentations a shot. Running something up the chain at an independent means walking across the room or just down the hall.
They have the flexibility to react to the events and needs of their communities quickly. They can partner with others in those communities to provide benefits greater than what we could provide alone.
Most newspapers walk a delicate tightrope financially. Most balance being a for-profit business that performs a service that, ideally, is not profit driven.
At the Butler Eagle for instance, other streams of revenue, like a billboard company and commercial printing, help support the journalism.
It’s not an easy balance to maintain, and when it starts to slip, it can hurt everyone.
I have seen publications make the mistake of not listening to the readers they exist to serve. Coverage gets cut in the interest of saving money. That leads to a reduction in readership as the community decides “there’s nothing in the paper.” In turn, persuading businesses to spend ad dollars becomes harder, as less readers means less reach for ads. Revenue declines, so the newspaper makes cuts, so readers stop reading, so ads get harder to sell and so on. Eventually, the local paper is reduced to little more than a community newsletter or it folds entirely.
It can happen quickly. All it takes is a few bad decisions and apathy from the community for a thriving paper to begin to spiral.
I could cite statistics on increased crime rates, lower literacy rates, reduced civic engagement and a whole host of other things that happen when a community loses its local newspaper; but that game of telephone may best illustrate the point.
So here at the Butler Eagle, we’re actively reaching out to hear from readers. We want to use your feedback to help inform our choices so we can put our resources and efforts where they’ll benefit Butler County most.
And the economics of the local news industry is as challenging for us as anyone. Without the community, just maintaining what we provide now is going to be a constantly increasing challenge. But by partnering with the community, we believe we can go beyond that and do much more.
We’re asking you to consider checking it out at impact.butlereagle.com and to keep us in mind this GivingTuesday and beyond to continue to ensure Butler County doesn’t have to rely on a game of telephone to learn what's happening.
