Butler’s aces, catcher make PA all-state baseball team after historic season
Weeks after making the PIAA Class 6A championship, Butler baseball’s three biggest names are all-state honorees.
The Golden Tornado’s ace pitchers Kyle Casteel and Nolan Stefaniak, as well as their battery mate, senior catcher Mavrik Clement, were named Class 6A first-team all-stars by the Pennsylvania State Baseball Coaches Association on Wednesday.
All three were Butler Eagle all-county first team last week, and Stefaniak was named the Butler Eagle Baseball Player of the Year and its 2025-26 Male Athlete of the Year in the past two weeks.
Stefaniak, a two-way talent heading to Penn State next year, went 8-2 on the mound this season with a 1.18 ERA and 85 strikeouts in 59.1 innings. He hit .364 with 20 RBIs and two home runs.
Casteel, a West Virginia commit who could hear his name called in the MLB draft July 11-13 along with Stefaniak, was a perfect 10-0 on the mount with a 0.64 ERA and 103 strikeouts in 65.2 innings.
Clement, a Pitt pledge, hit .312 with 14 RBIs and three homers for a team that won its first WPIAL crown this year.
Here are the full all-state rosters:
First Team
Pitchers: Kyle Casteel, Butler; Nolan Stefaniak, Butler; Cole Moody, Muhlenberg; Ben Kulp, Wilson; Ryne Mills, Chambersburg
Catchers: Liam Onofry, Delaware Valley; Jacob Carrasco, Manheim Township
Infield: Shane Monaghan, Coatesville; Brody Stump, Plymouth-Whitemarsh; D’Vonte Rivers, Wyoming Valley West; Chase Bonner, Neshaminy; Carlton Crane, Pennsbury; Ryan Jenkins, Waynesboro
Outfield: Santiago Rodriguez, Freedom; Colin Andrews, Freedom; Jaden Freeze, South Western; Emile Chanoine, Cheltenham; Tim Lengle, Wilson
Athlete: Caden Schmidt, La Salle; Graham Keen, Mt. Lebanon
Second Team
Pitchers: Keller Bradley, Pennsbury; Matt Gryn, Neshaminy; Camryn Simes, Ephrata; Sean Kinzeler, Coatesville
Catchers: Lucas Naughton, Williamsport; Mavrik Clement, Butler
Infield: Logan Hearity, Hazleton; Jack Haugen, Cheltenham; Gavin Dirita, Bonner-Predergast; Luke Sedor, Spring-Ford; Liam Quinn, Spring-Ford; Janser Paredes, Reading
Outfield: Blake Secrest, Cedar Cliff; Rylan Nichols, Waynesboro; Brady Simock, Northampton; Colton Orlando, McDowell; Deshawn White, Williamsport
Athlete: Seb Shulsky, Canon-McMillan; Rowan Walker, State College
...
First Team
Pitchers: Noah Farrell, DuBois; Vince Boland, Hollidaysburg; Austin Havertine, Radnor; Brady Scranton, Lampeter-Strasburg; Greyson Bell, Daniel Boone
Catchers: Trey Wingard, DuBois; Brady Youngblood, Dallas
Infield: Owen Rozzi, West Chester East; Cam Rakaczewski, Greencastle-Antrim; Mason Dinkfelt, DuBois; Luke Willliams, Franklin Regional; Max Vollmer, Plum; Beau Widdick, Pittston
Outfield: Aidan Willard, Palmyra; Dominick Zangardi, Dallas; Josh Banks, Hollidaysburg; Austin Cwynar, Pine-Richland; James Wall, Lampeter-Strasburg
Athlete: Nick Bradley, Abington Heights; Jack Lloyd, Whitehall
Second Team
Pitchers: Logan Plummer, Pine-Richland; Chase Woodring, Southern Lehigh; AJ Feleppa, Meadville; Austin Smith, ELCO; Braden Kemmerer, Plum
Catchers: Jacoby Harnen, Pittston; Hunter Strohm, Lower Dauphin
Infield: Alexander Stirr, Pocono Mountain East; Nico D’Orazio, Upper St. Clair; Nate Lord, Twin Valley; Mason Mierley, Hollidaysburg; Tanner Destefano, Penn-Trafford; Evan Yeckel, Shaler
Outfield: Matteo Weber, Montour; Braden Davis, Penncrest; Evan Gonzalez, Abington Heights; Avery Horst, Greencastle-Antrim; Logan Matrisch, Penn-Trafford
Athlete: Cole Short, Latrobe; Ben Husted, Pine-Richland
…
First Team
Pitchers: Adrian Gonzalez, Northern Lebanon; Brady Guzzie, Conwell-Egan; Zack Lehman, Bellefonte; Brady Sell, Archbishop Wood; Kingston Krotec, Hopewell
Catchers: Jovi De Jesus, East Pennsboro; Ethan Shank, Indiana
Infield: Charlie Manzi, Indiana; Connor Bergman, Belle Vernon; Avery Chenoweth, Kennard-Dale; Gavin Angotti, Ringgold; Eric Foster Jr., East Pennsboro; Isaak Stewart, Hamburg
Outfield: Noah Hoffer, Kennard-Dale; Eddie Rosado, Holy Ghost Prep; Matt Evans, Holy Ghost Prep; Chase Cavallaro, Archbishop Wood; Matthew Vitale, Eastern York
Athlete: Jacob Harris, Kennard-Dale; Logan Kirby, Montoursville
Second Team
Pitchers: Ryan Seibert, Easst Pennsboro; Colt Hagans, Somerset; Gavin Holmes, Kennard-Dale; Dominick Dunkel, Valley; Vincent Leoni, Bishop McDevitt
Catchers: Oliver Thornburg, Bellefonte; Charlie Smetana, Hopewell
Infield: Evan Mattern, Bellefonte; Carson Glose, Pope John Paul II; Brady Flynn, Athens; Joe Romanowsky, Mid Valley; Nick Mills, Mid Valley; Jackson Kiser, General McLane
Outfield: Noah Hubert, Saucon Valley; Braeden Fortney, Bellefonte; Ben McDonald, Hopewell; Nikolas Heakins, Valley; Brody Aldenderfer, Montoursville
Athlete: Quinn Bramble, Eastern York; Carter Davis, Blackhawk
...
First Team
Pitchers: Logan Zynn, Pequea Valley; Aaron Lake, Ellwood City; Branson Diller, Bermudian Springs; Matthew Santillo, Riverside (7); Cameron Pengelly, Palmerton
Catchers: Jordan Keller, Ellwood City; Jason Klokis, Mt. Carmel
Infield: Ian Shipley, Mt. Pleasant; Vinny Pezzuolo, Mohawk; Eddie Diaz, Bristol; Karson Engle, Upper Dauphin; Adam Sorensen, Montrose; Brock Bryson, Huntingdon
Outfield: Nick Bohenek, Riverside (2); Cole Guy, Bristol; Jaylen Delaney, Mt. Carmel; Jose Sosa, Riverside (2); Clemente Cintron, Notre Dame-Green Pond
Athlete: Cayden Vishnesky, Pen Argyl; Luke Rzodkiewicz, Fairview
Second Team
Pitchers: Brayden Holbert, Bloomsburg; James Keefer, Warrior Run; Michael Cejrowski Jr., Seton La Salle; Maxwell Mascho, Wellsboro; Mason Stets, Dunmore
Catchers: Coen Tennis, Wellsboro; Troy McNichol, Central Martinsburg
Infield: Brendan Gilliland, Troy; Marek Mascho, Wellsboro; Brayden Hennessy, Fairview; Dylan Meyer, Riverside (7); Brayden Heller, Bermudian Springs; Jaxton Henry, Brandywine
Outfield: Landen Wagner, Lewisburg; Ethan Reck, Huntingdon; Aidan Hoffman, Biglerville; Joey Ortiz, Bristol; Wyatt Kustenbauder, Tyrone
Athlete: Griffen Harrington, Warrior Run; Teegan Byers, Bermudian Springs
…
First Team
Pitchers: Briar Persing, Montgomery; Hunter Krahe, Mercyhurst Prep; Jordan Jagger, Mountain View; Josh Zahurak, Halifax; Peyton Schley, Tri-Valley
Catchers: Blake Leslie, Saegertown; Alden Felker, Elk Lake
Infield: Caden Hopper, Southern Columbia; Nathan Rickel, Neshannock; Zack Kruszewski, Mercyhurst Prep; Chase McCole, Shenandoah Valley; Jonathan Delia, Bishop McCort; Leo Nockley, Wyoming Seminary
Outfield: Colin Dinyar, Conemaugh Township; Connor Latrechiano, York Catholic; Randiel Araujo, Executive Education; Brandon Labs, Faith Christian; Jagger Verbit, Faith Christian
Athlete: Brendan Marvin, Blue Ridge; Noah Wilson, Faith Christian
Second Team
Pitchers: Eli Miller, Halifax; Jamon Ranck, Mt. Union; Levi Everitt, Southern Columbia; Jonathan Drawbaugh, Camp Hill; Cayden Witmer, Williams Valley
Catchers: Fletcher Thompson, Williams Valley; Cam Swogger, Bellwood-Antis
Infield: Dominic Marranca, Holy Redeemer; Isaac Anker, Carlynton; Nolan Plesnarski, Minersville; Alan Evans, Schuylkill Haven; Ryan Cameron, Neshannock; Chase Yoder, Schuylkill Haven
Outfield: Oscar Roa, Executive Education; Eric Firle, Carlynton; Matthew Kocher, Halifax; Lucas Rummel, Windber; Ayden Hockenbroch, Southern Columbia
Athlete: William Shaffer, Saegertown; Braylon Wagner, Redbank Valley
…
First Team
Pitchers: Noah Emswiler, Eden Christian; Carter Himes, DuBois Central Catholic; Matthew Gilmore, Elk County; Riley King, Dock Mennonite; Austin Holbritter, York Christian
Catchers: Austin Mann, Southern Fulton; Mason Campagna, Claysburg-Kimmel
Infield: Brady Hull, Eden Christian; Elijah Johns, Juniata Valley; Kellen Veileeux, Port Allegany; Kyle Gilson, West Middlesex; Nathan Show, Rockwood; Brooks Norris, Southern Fulton
Outfield: Bradon Howe, High Point Baptist; Ethan Kratz, Dock Mennonite; Gavin Treon, Claysburg-Kimmel; Wyatt Watterson, Clarion; Hunter Pearce, Harmony
Athlete: Stephen Karinch, Nativity BVM; Max Black, Serra Catholic
Second Team
Pitchers: Eli Sheesley, Blacklick Valley; Aiden Thomas, Meyersdale; Colton Swenson, High Point Baptist; Carter Vogt, Meyersdale; Reese Wagner, Northern Cambria
Catchers: CJ Grove, St. Joseph’s Catholic; Noah Cunningham, York Christian
Infield: Mason Bicht, Dock Mennonite; Cole Yoder, Meyersdale; Ben Martin, York Christian; Caleb Foytack, St. Joseph’s Catholic; Paul Hendershot, Southern Fulton; Evan Burton, DuBois Central Catholic
Outfield: Trey Booz, High Point Baptist; Nicholas Wilfong, Port Allegany; Trey Keating, Nativity BVM; Nash Budner, Homer-Center; Ethan Scalia, Juniata Valley
Athlete: Dylan Smail, Clarion; Jeremy Slick, Forest City
