Site last updated: Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Policy may require Seneca seniors to audition for commencement speaker

JACKSON TWP — A potential policy change at Seneca Valley could see auditions, and not academic achievement, determine commencement speakers at each year’s graduation ceremonies.

Matt McKinley, assistant superintendent, said at Monday night’s school board meeting that a district policy change will be up for a vote at next week’s meeting.

The policy change would switch the commencement speakers from the valedictorian and salutatorian to students in good standing who succeed in auditioning to give a speech.

McKinley said the current timing of determining which two students earn the first and second academic slots heaps undue stress on contenders at the end of the year.

He said other school districts in Western Pennsylvania use the audition method to determine which seniors will give speeches at commencement ceremonies.

The valedictorian and salutatorian will continue to be announced at the end of each school year, McKinley said.

“I’m struggling with this,” said school board member Leslie Bredl.

She said the top two seniors work very hard and part of their reward is the status of speaking at commencement.

She asked administration if they could review how and when the top students are determined so the tradition of valedictorian and salutatorian speaking at graduation could continue with less stress.

If the policy change passes, Bredl asked that the upcoming freshman class be the first graduating class to participate in the new process instead of the 2022-23 seniors.

“It’s an unexpected, unanticipated change,” she said.

Jim Nickel, board president, said his thinking is along the same lines as Bredl’s, and that he will discuss the issue with administration before next week’s vote.

Superintendent Tracy Vitale said because the new school year is about to begin, a vote on the policy must take place next week.

“I just fear that we are not rewarding those individuals who have achieved those levels,” Bredl said.

More in

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS