Handyman accused of scamming customers
A local “businessman” has been charged with four instances of deceptive business practices related to alleged home improvement fraud.
"He admitted that he was heavily into heroin at the time and that he was ‘robbing Peter to pay Paul,’“ said the investigating state trooper in one of the affidavits.
State police filed cases against Billy J. Abrams, 41, of Butler, on March 24, March 29 and March 30, all including similar felony counts of failing to complete services paid in advance, theft and deceptive business practices.
Abrams is housed in Butler County Prison. He is held in lieu of $25,000 bond on one of the four cases.
According to charging documents, Abrams was operating under his business called Billy’s Plumbing and Heating during the alleged offenses.
Police said they received the first report Feb. 4 from a Penn Township resident who had hired Abrams to remove and replace an old boiler. The resident said he paid for some of the job up front on Aug. 3 and had an invoice to show for it.
“The invoice detailed that the total cost due for material, the new boiler and additional parts was $4,800,” police said. "(The man) related that Abrams was to return within the month to compete the work because Abrams was supposed to get wrist surgery in September.“
The resident told officers he made calls later to Abrams, who then told him the parts were broken in transit and their replacements were on back order. Police said Abrams never completed the work.
Police said less than a week later, on Feb. 8, they were called to a Harrisville apartment building whose owner claimed he paid Abrams $3,610 on Nov. 17 to install new furnaces in two units.
The owner told police Abrams installed only one of the furnaces. The owner claimed Abrams told him the second furnace was damaged, and its replacement was back ordered.
“(The owner) related that Abrams failed to contact him until Dec. 30, when he informed him that he had been sick with COVID-19, and that he would get the second furnace to him Jan. 3,” police said.
Police said the second furnace never was installed, resulting in a loss of about $1,805.
Police said on Feb. 11, a Summit Township resident claimed Abrams failed to replace a furnace and air-conditioning unit at a cost of $6,050, prepaid Sept. 16.
“I observed a text message conversation between the (homeowner) and Abrams detailing that Abrams had been sick and that he would get in touch when he was feeling better,” police said.
Police said Abrams stopped communicating with the homeowner after Oct. 3.
For the fourth filing, police responded March 27 to a Clay Township home, where the resident said Abrams was paid $2,416 on March 25 to replace a furnace. The homeowner told police Abrams never returned after taking measurements for the job.
The owner told police she saw Abrams had been arrested for similar incidents and then received a call from him about attempting to work out an agreement.
Police conducted a second interview with Abrams in which he said he remembered the Clay Township resident’s job after his first interview with police.
“He related that he called them to attempt to set up a way to pay them back for failed services,” police said.
Abrams has preliminary hearings April 13, two on April 19 and April 20, before district judges Joseph Nash, Lewis Stoughton and Sue Haggerty, respectively.
