Site last updated: Monday, November 16, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Eckstein sends message to Bar Assoc.

Focus on lawyers in trouble with law

Butler County Commissioner Jim Eckstein says the Butler County Bar Association should worry about attorneys who get into trouble instead of scrutinizing him.

Eckstein said at the commissioners meeting Wednesday the bar association never chided former attorneys Bernie Flugher, Art Rauschenberger and Samuel “Joe” Brydon for their actions.

All three men lost their licenses to practice law since 2012.

“Is the bar association’s outrage over my right of free speech ... or a political power play,” Eckstein said.

The bar association on June 27 voted 31 to 0 to determine if there should be a response to what Eckstein said at the June 19 commissioners meeting about the appearance of impropriety involving the elimination of jury commissioners.

Eckstein maintains the May 23 vote to dispense with the part-time elected posts was politically motivated.

Since his June 19 comments mentioned President Judge Thomas Doerr and the possibility of jury tampering in a defamation case against Eckstein, the bar association became involved.

A three-person committee is investigating whether Eckstein’s remarks warrant a response from the association.

Eckstein said Wednesday the bar association’s obligation to defend the judiciary does not mean it can hinder his free speech.

Attorney Mike Gallagher of the Butler firm Murrin, Taylor, Flach, Gallagher & May, president of the bar association, said in an interview the investigation is appropriate under the circumstances.

“Anyone making defamatory, malicious or false statements is subject to review,” Gallagher said.

He said the investigation is under way.

“It’s beyond the preliminary stage,” Gallagher said.

During the meeting, Eckstein detailed the three attorneys’ cases.

Flugher in April 2012 was sentenced to two years of probation for his role in a mortgage fraud scheme.

Rauschenberger last year submitted a written resignation, which is a disbarment by consent, to the disciplinary board of the state Supreme Court. The contents of the letter were confidential.

Brydon in June pleaded guilty to stealing more than $544,000 from three estates he was hired to settle. His sentencing is set for Aug. 19.

Eckstein spoke about the late John Davis, the former owner of Wholesale Plumbing & Heating in Butler, whose estate was missing more than $368,000 after Brydon did legal work involving it.

“Where was the bar association’s public outcry for Mr. Davis and his family? I couldn’t find it anywhere,” Eckstein said.

Gallagher declined to discuss those attorney’s cases.

“I don’t need to address his (Eckstein’s) specific comments,” Gallagher said.

He said despite Eckstein previously referring to the bar association investigating as being a joke, the commissioner spends an abundant amount of time talking about it.

Eckstein pointed out the bar association investigation was approved by a fraction of the total membership of 120.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS