Peoples TWP rate hike opposed
Many Butler County residents oppose a proposed 28 percent rate increase for residential gas customers of Peoples TWP.
More that 130 people Tuesday evening attended a state Public Utility Commission hearing to take public input about the proposed increase, and 28 of them testified.
The proposed rate hike would increase monthly bills for the average residential customer from $79.22 to $101.71, an increase of $270 annually.
Commercial customers will see a rate increase from $208.53 to $219.77 a month and industrial customers will see an increase from $2,951 to $3,052 a month.
The company is proposing the rate hikes to fund the replacement of 148 miles of pipe installed about 70 years ago. About 70 percent of the total lines already have been replaced.
All who testified spoke against the increase.
Marge Davis Harding of Sarver said the increase will have a severe impact on all customers, particularly older ones and those on fixed incomes.
She said all customers want safe and modern infrastructure. However, she said people who need to make personal upgrades do not ask their employer for a raise.
“Instead, they budget,” she said.
She said Peoples TWP should do the same.
Chuck Snyder of Renfrew noted the Legislature in 2012 passed law to allow utility companies to add a distribution system improvement charge to bills, which allows companies to charge extra to help pay for aging facilities without having to request a rate increase.
“My concern is Peoples already is using this,” Snyder said. “Where does it end?”
Tom Edwards of Butler said natural gas is the cheapest its ever been, but TWP still is seeking a rate increase.
“I think it's ridiculous,” Edwards said.
He wondered why residents are getting a 28 percent rate increase, but commercial customers are getting only a 5 percent increase and industrial customers get only a 3 percent increase.
John Mall of Butler has been a gas customer for 54 years and said he has no problem with periodic, reasonable rate increases.“A 28 percent increase is not reasonable, in my eyes,” Mall said.He said the increase will hurt not only retirees, but also young families and middle-aged people with children in college.He also said he found it odd the county is on a lot of Marcellus Shale natural gas, but the gas bill might increase.“That doesn't sit too well with me,” Mall said.Dawn Spielvogel of Center Township said it is no shock the 70-year-old infrastructure needs to be replaced, but she asked why customers should pay for the replacement.“That is not fair,” she said.She said the company should have been setting money aside to pay for it. She wondered, if the increase is passed, how would the public would know how the money is spent.Duane Kyper of Butler noted T.W. Phillips Gas and Oil Co. was bought by SteelRiver Infrastructure Fund North America LP in 2011.He said SteelRiver is a private firm that buys utilities companies, and its main goal is to have a 15 percent return for investors.“This is what they do,” Kyper said.He said the PUC approving the increase would be “another vote for the bad guys on Wall Street.”Michael Lazaroff of Saxonburg said the increase is excessive and represents “corporate greed.” He noted the increase would provide the company with an 11.25 percent return in equity.He said he generally is not in favor of government regulation, but there are some areas where it should be done.“This is one of them,” Lazaroff said.Betty Kraus of Butler said she is on a fixed income and has her utilities on a budget plan.Last month, she said her bill increased from $62 to $116. She called the company's billing department, and it lowered her bill to $84.“I'm not quite sure what is going on at TWP,” Kraus said.Vernon Wise of Butler said the increase really does not have much to do with replacing pipeline.He said the PUC has to set rates so companies get a fair return on investments. This would allow SteelRiver to get up to the 28 percent increase as a return on its original investment in buying Peoples TWP.He said he is concerned that Wall Street has picked up on this and will start buying companies regulated by the PUC.“We are just seeing the beginning of what's happening,” Wise said.The PUC will take into account input from this hearing as well as input from the company and other parties from other hearings before it will make the final decision on the rate increase.If the increase is granted, it will take effect no later than January 2014.
