Talk of theTown
The Redevelopment Authority of Butler's Centre City project will bring a new hotel downtown, but it won't be the first hotel there.
Numerous hotels populated the city throughout the first half of the last century, including the Willard, Park and Atlas hotels.
But perhaps the most notable of them all was the Nixon Hotel, which opened in 1906 in Diamond Park.
“The Nixon was 'the hotel' in downtown Butler,” said Larry Berg, 82, of Butler. “The Nixon was the center of social activities. That's where all the businessmen and ladies' groups went for lunch.”
While it was the hot spot for residents of the city, the Nixon got a large portion of its business from travelers.
“It was very popular because of traveling salesmen,” said Martin O'Brien, 82, of Butler. “(Route) 422 was the major east-west highway at that time and Butler was about halfway between New York City and Chicago.”
O'Brien was the attorney who eventually represented the redevelopment authority in the 1970s to get the Nixon building torn down. He remembers the impact the hotel had on Butler over the years.
“I remember being in it through my whole life,” O'Brien said. “When I was a young boy, my father would go up to buy The New York Times every Sunday.
“I remember seeing the stock boards in the lobby back in the 1930s.”
As O'Brien entered high school in the 1940s all the service clubs had their dinners there.
“It was the center of town and business,” O'Brien said. “It was a thriving, booming place at that point.”
The Willard Hotel was the Nixon's biggest rival, although it did not have as high a status.Joan Chew, 83, of Butler, has fond memories of the Willard.“The Willard was not quite as fashionable, though I preferred it, to be honest,” Chew said. “I preferred the food to that at the Nixon.”Despite her own taste, Chew said the Nixon was far more popular.“I was never upstairs but the lounge on the Diamond was where everyone went to entertain,” Chew said. “Everyone went to the Nixon.”O'Brien agreed the Willard was not as popular as the Nixon, but still had its share of visitors.“They had a very popular dining room as well,” O'Brien said. “It was smaller than the Nixon but was still popular.”“After World War II it became very popular for returning GIs. The small bar there was called the 'Fox Den.'”Chew said both hotels were vital to the community.“Both always were busy with events and parties,” she said. “And there were no other places around. Holiday Inn and Rachel's were added much later.”Chew said the other hotels in the city were not nearly as popular but did serve a purpose.“The Atlas was the hotel people traveling through on train would spend a night,” she said. “It wasn't like the Nixon or Willard.”But the business at the hotels began to decline in the late 1950s.“I began practicing law in the 1950s in what is now the Lafayette apartment building across the street from the Nixon,” O'Brien said. “The lawyers met at the hotel for lunch frequently. The meals were very good.”“I also went there frequently for dinner, but only a few times were there a lot of other people there.”O'Brien, who later became a county judge, said he could see the demise of the hotel through the years from his office across the street.“I could see the number of rooms that were lighted each night,” he said. “And gradually their business just declined.”O'Brien said it was obvious why the hotel began to lose business.“First of all there was the opening of the turnpike which bypassed Butler,” O'Brien said. “The development of motels along the interstate hurt it as well. They were the newer, modern facility. The Nixon was old.”The state of the hotel declined after the death of Simeon Nixon, the hotel's owner, in 1946.“The hotel just deteriorated over the years,” Berg said. “And then the Holiday Inn was built in 1965 and took away a lot of the Nixon's business.”
By 1969, the Nixon was ruled to be blighted and was set to be demolished to make room for the redevelopment authority's urban renewal projects.But C. Stewart Shoemaker, the owner of the hotel after Nixon, did not give up on the building without a fight.“We went through six to seven years of litigation and the case made its way to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court on two or three occasions,” O'Brien said. “Ultimately the authority prevailed and the hotel was demolished.”The ongoing court battle caused great controversy in the city.“I believe that part of the opposition was the philosophical basis that the government should not take private property for the development of downtown,” O'Brien said.The hotel's history also played a role in the debates.“Preservationists thought it was a terrible idea to raze the hotel because it was a landmark,” Berg said. “It certainly caused a lot of commotion.”Shoemaker died in April 1975, a month before the legal battle ended. The court ruled the authority had the right to do what was best for the city and awarded it the property. The authority ended up paying Shoemaker's estate $400,000 for the property.The Morgan Center and the U.S. Post Office were the projects that replaced the demolished hotel.The Willard Hotel had a similar fate as the Nixon.By the 1960s, the same factors that closed the Nixon had an impact on the Willard.Berg, who owned two radio stations in Butler when he moved to the city in the 1960s, recalls the state of the hotel upon his arrival.“It wasn't nice at all,” he said. “We had offices in there when we first came and it was in terrible shape. It was not well kept.”After the Nixon was demolished, the Willard Hotel continued until 1978 when it was bought by the Butler County Motor Co. and demolished. Now it is the site of Butler County Ford's used truck lot.The Centre City project looks to revitalize the legacy of hotels in the city.Construction of the $10 million Marriott SpringHill Suites is expected to begin this fall and take about a year to finish.It is expected to have 75 rooms, multiple conference rooms, and a three-tier parking garage.
