Site last updated: Monday, November 16, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Results mixed on SRU review

Keith Dils
Council looks at education program

SLIPPERY ROCK — The National Council on Teacher Quality’s annual Teacher Prep Review gave a mixed review to the Slippery Rock University education program.

SRU received one star for undergraduate elementary education, two-and-a-half stars for undergraduate secondary education and one-and-a-half stars for graduate secondary education.

Programs are ranked from zero to four stars.

Keith Dils, dean of SRU’s college of education, said the report is flawed.

“It’s not a good methodology,” Dils said.

In fall 2012, there were 321 students in SRU’s undergraduate elementary education, 364 students in its secondary education and 48 in its graduate secondary education program.

The review, released in June, does not evaluate teachers, but looks at the quality of teaching preparation programs.

Some programs at California (Pa.) University, Clarion University, Holy Family University in Philadelphia and Marywood University in Scranton received warnings because they earned zero stars.

Others programs, such as those at Bloomsburg University, Mansfield University and Saint Joseph’s University, were noted for receiving three stars.

Dils said that the council asked for certain documents, such as syllabi, but did not get other documents, and also did not make any calls or visits to the school.

“We have reams and reams of data,” Dils said. “They didn’t get any of that information.”

He said the NCTQ report would be better if it was structured similar to those used when a college is seeking accreditation. Dils noted that the college is accredited with the National Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education.

He said the college has a high student retention rate and that students come in with high SAT scores and good class ranks.

“We bring in strong students to begin with,” Dils said.

He said that students have to have a high grade point average just to get into the teacher education program. Students also have to do rigorous projects while in college.

“Our students do overwhelmingly well with those projects,” Dils said.

He said the report stated the college did a good job of providing feedback to student teachers, but said it did not exercise the right to select a cooperating teacher for the student teacher to work with.

Dils said that the college does select cooperating teachers with help from schools, but the NCTQ did not ask for documents showing that. He noted that the college also has cooperating teacher workshops, but the report does not reflect that, either.

He said he is disappointed that the NCTQ did not do a more comprehensive report.

“We’re very proud of our programs,” Dils said.

However, because training teachers is challenging and multifaceted, Dils said there is always room for improvement.

“We’re open to learning,” Dils said.

Katie Moyer, a spokesman for the NCTQ, said that Dils’ issues with the report are mirrored by many education deans.

Moyer said that the NCTQ looked at 11 sources of data from each school.

“Syllabi were not the only source of data,” Moyer said.

She said some school officials may have misunderstood the point of the report, which is to assess the design of education programs. Moyer said that the methodology was reviewed by education experts and advisory panels.

She acknowledged that programs that score poorly can have positive aspects, but said the purpose of the report is to evaluate the design of education programs.

“Without a solid design, no program can succeed,” Moyer said.

The NCTQ is a Washington, D.C., based group that advocates for reforms to improve teachers.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS