Man sues to clear record, buy rifle
PITTSBURGH — A Butler man is suing the Pennsylvania State Police because he claims he wasn’t allowed to buy a hunting rifle after he was erroneously identified as having been committed for mental health treatment.
Jeffrey L. Burtner, no age available, is asking the United States District Court to force the state police to issue a declaration stating that he never was involuntarily committed, and he is legally clear to buy a weapon.
According to the lawsuit, the issue came about when Burtner tried to buy a hunting rifle at Sportsmans Supply in Butler on May 24, 2012.
The store performed the legally required background check on Burtner, and it came back with a denial.
On later challenge and inquiry, Burtner — who has previously purchased weapons without issue — learned that he was denied because the Pennsylvania Instant Check System had deemed him “as a mental defective.” The system wrongly indicated Burtner was committed to Butler Memorial Hospital on June 28,1992.
People who have been involuntarily committed to a mental institution are prohibited from purchasing, owning or possessing firearms.
But Burtner, according to the lawsuit, had never been committed to a mental health institution. Burtner’s attorney, Joshua Prince of Bechtelsville, reportedly determined the only records Butler Memorial Hospital has for treating Burtner is a 2009 chest X-ray and a 2010 blood test. The hospital reportedly has no record of treating Burtner for a mental health commitment. Still, Burtner claims in the lawsuit that a state police attorney advised him that he would have to sue to challenge and correct the information in the state’s instant check system.
A spokesman for the state police could not be reached. Typically, they do not comment on pending litigation.
Neither Burtner nor Prince could be reached for comment.
Burtner’s lawsuit also asks that the state police expunge any records erroneously indicating that Burtner had been committed. Additionally, it seeks compensation for his attorney’s fees.
