Store worker accused of stealing
BUTLER TWP — A convenience store employee is suspected of concocting an elaborate ruse to steal more than $5,000.
During the alleged scheme in March, Sherrie L. Stiefel pocketed store receipts she was supposed to deposit and elicited the help of unsuspecting friends to make it look like she was the victim, court documents said.
But good police work, aided by the suspect’s own cell phone, helped unravel the twisted plot.
Butler Township police Thursday charged the 41-year-old Stiefel of Slippery Rock with a felony count of theft. She also is charged with filing a false report to police.
The defendant’s brush with the law began March 24 when she left work at the Honey Bear store in Butler with $5,391.17 in store receipts she was supposed to deposit in the bank.
But instead of going to the bank, she drove to the apartment of Mike Cumblidge and Heather Kuhrt in Butler, where she smoked crack cocaine, documents said.
She also recited a cover story that was part of the con.
Stiefel told Cumblidge that she had “spent too much money” and that her boyfriend was “going to kill her” when he found out, according to a police affidavit.
She asked Cumblidge to take her purse from her car while she shopped at the Wal-Mart in the Butler Crossing shopping center in Butler Township. For his help, she promised to leave “a few rocks of crack” for him in the purse, police said.
An unwitting pawn in her scheme, police believe, Cumblidge agreed, and Stiefel in the early morning of March 25 drove him to New Castle Road, dropping him off near the shopping plaza.
She drove to Wal-Mart and went inside, leaving her purse in the car.
Cumblidge, meanwhile, walked to the defendant’s car and when no one was around it, he entered the vehicle. He found the purse and the crack, which he smoked, documents said.
About three minutes in the car, he left, taking the purse. He tossed it away under a tree by another store at the plaza.
Cumblidge started walking home before Kuhrt picked him up in her car.
Back at the Wal-Mart, Stiefel reported to police about 2:40 a.m. that someone had stolen the purse from her car while she was shopping.
She falsely claimed the purse contained the money from the Honey Bear that she was to have deposited.
Police asked why she had not deposited the money after leaving work.
Stiefel purported that she was running late for her granddaughter’s birthday party and forgot to make the bank drop, documents said.
She claimed she drove home after the party. Only then did she remember the money. She told police she drove back to Butler, presumably to take the money to the bank.
But on her way, she claimed she stopped at the Wal-Mart “to do some Easter shopping,” the police affidavit said.
Police reviewed the Wal-Mart video surveillance, which showed an unknown man entering her car at 1:42 a.m.
Detective Sgt. Nathan Teslik later obtained a search warrant for the defendant’s cell phone records, which showed incoming and outgoing calls and texts between Stiefel and Cumblidge and Kuhrt.
Police on May 10 interviewed Cumblidge, whose account of his encounter with Stiefel exposed her bogus alibi, documents said.
Investigators believe he was unaware that Stiefel had stolen any money.
“Cumblidge thought he was just helping Stiefel get out of a jam with her boyfriend for spending too much money, the affidavit aid.
Kuhrt also was unaware of the defendant’s theft or the suspected scheme to hide the crime.
Accompanied by her attorney, Stiefel in May met with investigators for an interview at the police station.
She recounted the alleged ruse, documents said, and admitted that “the theft of the money was all her fault.”
A telephone call to Steifel’s attorney, Stevenson Suess of Butler, was not immediately returned.
